-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 2.5k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
cargo check --test foo compiles too much #4059
Comments
After investigating this issue, it seems that the problem comes from this line in targets.append(&mut propose_indicated_targets(pkg, tests, "test", Target::is_test, test)?); This line adds integration tests that match the This could be fixed by passing the |
Should I take care of this issue in the same PR or should I open another one once the first is closed? |
@burningmind oh feel free to take care of this issue in your PR! No need for a separate one. |
- Add `--profile test` flag to `cargo check` that will enable checking of unit tests. - `--tests` will implicitly enable checking of unit tests within the lib. - Don't implicitly compile binaries when using just `--test` filters. - Fix erroneously linking tests when run with `--test`. Fixes rust-lang#3431, rust-lang#4003, rust-lang#4059, rust-lang#4330.
Add unit test checking to `cargo check` This is an extension of PR #4039, fixing #3431, #4003, #4059, #4330. The fixes for #4059 can potentially be separated into a separate PR, though there may be some overlap. The general gist of the changes: - Add `--profile test` flag to `cargo check` that will enable checking of unit tests. - `--tests` will implicitly enable checking of unit tests within the lib (checks the same targets as `cargo test`). This affects the `check`, `test`, and `build` commands. - `--benches` behaves similarly by using the same targets as `cargo bench`. - Fix erroneously linking tests when run with `--test`. There is one thing I did not do because I wanted more feedback on what others think the expected behavior should be. What should the behavior of `--all-targets` be? This patch does not (yet) make any changes to its behavior. My initial thinking is that it should *add* a target of `--lib --bins --profile test`, but that essentially means the lib and bin targets will be checked twice (and thus any errors/warnings outside of `#[cfg(test)]` will appear twice, which may be confusing, and generally take twice as long to run). I can add that, but I think it would require adding a new `All` variant to `CompileFilter` so that the code in `generate_targets` can detect this scenario. I wanted feedback before making a more extensive change like that. The downside of not adding it is that `--all-targets` will ignore unit tests (if you don't specify `--profile test`). Summary of the profiles used with this patch: Command | Lib | Bin foo | Test t1 | Example e1 | Bench b1 | ------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | `check` | check | check | - | - | - | `check --profile test` | check_test† | check_test† | - | - | - | `check --lib` | check | - | - | - | - | `check --lib --profile test` | check_test† | - | - | - | - | `check --bin foo` | check | check | - | - | - | `check -–bin foo –profile test` | check_test† | check_test† | - | - | - | `check --bins` | check | check | - | - | - | `check --test t1` | check | check | check_test | - | - | `check --tests` | check, check_test† | check, check_test† | check_test | check†, check_test† | - | `check --all-targets` | check, check_test† | check, check_test† | check_test | check, check_test† | check_test | † = different behavior from today
This is fixed by #4592. |
From a local compilation:
Notably nothing was compiled with metadata as an output.
cc @nrc
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: