Update ScenarioMIP config files in line with internal protocol v4 #1920

laurinks · 2024-12-09T09:37:54Z

Purpose of this PR

Update ScenarioMIP config files (REMIND standalone and coupling) according to Internal scenario protocol (v4) - ScenarioMIP main phase

Type of change

Update of non-default config files

Checklist:

My code follows the coding etiquette
I performed a self-review of my own code
I explained my changes within the PR, particularly in hard-to-understand areas
I checked that the in-code documentation is up-to-date
I adjusted the reporting in remind2 where it was needed
I adjusted forbiddenColumnNames in readCheckScenarioConfig.R in case the PR leads to deprecated switches
All automated model tests pass (FAIL 0 in the output of make test)
The changelog CHANGELOG.md has been updated correctly

laurinks · 2024-12-09T14:21:59Z

For transparency, here is a comparison of default ScenarioMIP scenarios with default REMIND scenarios:

High and Medium scenario differ from REMIND default scenarios only by Enhanced Weathering (EW)
Medium-Low, Low, and Very Low after High Overshoot only differ from REMIND in terms of climate policy timing and near-term settings (still evolving) and Enhanced Weathering (EW)
Very Low after Limited Overshoot differs from REMIND in a few characteristics that are currently discussed here. Once ScenarioMIP has converged on these, they will be harmonized with REMIND.

File comparison: /p/projects/rd3mod/github/repos/remindmodel/remind/develop/config/scenario_config.csv -> ./config/scenario_config_ScenarioMIP.csv
Columns deleted: c_ccscapratescen, c_tech_earlyreti_rate, capitalMarket, CES_parameters, cm_bioenergy_SustTax, cm_emiMktTarget, cm_prtpScen, extramappings_historic, regionmapping, slurmConfig
Columns added:   cm_maxProdBiolc, cm_taxCO2_historical, cm_taxCO2_historicalYr, cm_taxCO2_IncAfterPeakBudgYr, cm_taxCO2_interpolation, copyConfigFrom
Renamed columns: -
Renamed rows:    SSP2-NPi2025 -> SMIPv04-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def, SSP3-rollBack -> SMIPv04-H-SSP3-rollBack-def, SSP2-PkBudg1000 -> SMIPv04-L-SSP2-PkBudg1000-def, SSP2-EcBudg400 -> SMIPv04-VLHO-SSP2-EcBudg400-def, SSP1-PkBudg650 -> SMIPv04-VLLO-SSP1-PkBudg650-def

Changes in the scenarios:
~ SSP3-rollBack -> SMIPv04-H-SSP3-rollBack-def:
    cm_budgetCO2from2020: 0 -> 1150 (default: 1150)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    path_gdx_ref: SSP2-NPi2025 -> SMIPv04-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def
    path_gdx_refpolicycost: SSP3-NPi2025 -> SMIPv04-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def
    description: was changed (default: REMIND run with default settings)
~ SSP2-NPi2025 -> SMIPv04-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def:
    start: 1,AMT,2 -> 1
    cm_budgetCO2from2020: 0 -> 1150 (default: 1150)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    description: was changed (default: REMIND run with default settings)
+ SMIPv04-ML-SSP2-PkBudg1500-def was added.
~ SSP2-PkBudg1000 -> SMIPv04-L-SSP2-PkBudg1000-def:
    start: 1,AMT,2 -> 1
    cm_taxCO2_startyear: 75 -> 65 (default: -1)
    cm_taxCO2_regiDiff_endYr: "GLO 2050" -> GLO 2070 (default: "GLO 2050")
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    c_changeProdCost: 1 -> 5 (default: 5)
    path_gdx_ref: SSP2-NPi2025 -> SMIPv04-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def
    path_gdx_refpolicycost: SSP2-NPi2025 -> SMIPv04-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def
    description: was changed (default: REMIND run with default settings)
    cm_taxCO2_historical: NA -> 55 (default: gdx_ref)
    cm_taxCO2_historicalYr: NA -> 2028 (default: last)
    cm_taxCO2_IncAfterPeakBudgYr: NA -> 5 (default: 0)
~ SSP2-EcBudg400 -> SMIPv04-VLHO-SSP2-EcBudg400-def:
    start: 1,AMT,2 -> 1
    cm_implicitQttyTarget: (2080,2090,2100).GLO.tax.t.oae.all 5000 -> (2080,2090,2100,2110,2130,2150).GLO.tax.t.oae.all 5000 (default: off)
    path_gdx_ref: SSP2-NPi2025 -> SMIPv04-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def
    path_gdx_refpolicycost: SSP2-NPi2025 -> SMIPv04-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def
    description: was changed (default: REMIND run with default settings)
    cm_taxCO2_interpolation: NA -> one_step (default: off)
~ SSP1-PkBudg650 -> SMIPv04-VLLO-SSP1-PkBudg650-def:
    start: 1,AMT -> 1
    cm_taxCO2_startyear: 100 -> 75 (default: -1)
    cm_taxCO2_regiDiff_endYr: "GLO 2050" -> GLO 2050 (default: "GLO 2050")
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    c_ccsinjecratescen: 2 -> 5 (default: 1)
    cm_CESMkup_build: feelhpb 1.05, fehob 1.75, feheb 0.1 -> standard (default: standard)
    cm_CESMkup_ind: manual -> standard (default: standard)
    cm_CESMkup_ind_data: feh2_otherInd 1.04, feelhth_otherInd 0.4, feh2_cement 2.0, feelhth_chemicals 1.3, feh2_chemicals 1.04 -> "" (default: "")
    cm_tradecostBio: 0.5 -> 1 (default: 1)
    c_changeProdCost: 1 -> 5 (default: 5)
    path_gdx_ref: SSP2-NPi2025 -> SMIPv04-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def
    path_gdx_refpolicycost: SSP1-NPi2025 -> SMIPv04-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def
    description: was changed (default: REMIND run with default settings)
    cm_maxProdBiolc: NA -> 100 (default: off)
    cm_taxCO2_historical: NA -> 55 (default: gdx_ref)
    cm_taxCO2_historicalYr: NA -> 2028 (default: last)

laurinks · 2024-12-09T14:35:37Z

@dklein-pik : This fixes the problem in the coupling tests.
@flohump: Could you have a quick look at the coupled config to make sure everything is as intended on the MAgPIE side? Thanks!
@LaviniaBaumstark, @gunnar-pik, @robertpietzcker, @nicobauer, @strefler : For your information, I added the comparison between REMIND default scenarios and REMIND settings for ScenarioMIP (see comment). As you see, for High and Medium, EW is the only difference. I am also keeping variants without EW in the config for comparison/back-up.

flohump

Review for scenario_config_coupled_ScenarioMIP.csv
Column config/scenario_config.csv
|rcpXpX is not needed and can be safely removed.
We don't use climate change impacts in the ScenarioMIP runs. This is set by nocc_hist. Setting an addtional rcpXpX impact pathway is confusing.

Column no_ghgprices_land_until
SMIPv04-VLHO-SSP2-EcBudg400-def has y2035. Why 2035 and not 2030?

Everything else looks fine

laurinks · 2024-12-09T15:04:12Z

Column no_ghgprices_land_until
SMIPv04-VLHO-SSP2-EcBudg400-def has y2035. Why 2035 and not 2030?

Because we fix the scenario to the Medium scenario in 2030. REMIND cm_startyear is consistently set to 2035. The ScenarioMIP paper asks for the VLHO scenario to follow current policies in 2030, and only deviate thereafter. Motivations: delayed climate policy + sufficient difference between VLLO and VLHO for signal in ESMs.

…safely removed

laurinks · 2024-12-09T16:43:44Z

Summary of exchange with @dklein-pik and @flohump :

no_ghgprices_land_until = 20xx means that GHG prices will be set to zero (in MAgPIE) until and including the year 20xx.
Until 2030, climate policy in MAgPIE is implemented via NDC policies, thus no_ghgprices_land_until is always chosen to be 2030 or later.

For coupling configs, this implies:

All scenarios with REMIND cm_startyear <= 2035 use no_ghgprices_land_until = 2030.
All scenarios with REMIND cm_startyear >= 2040 use no_ghgprices_land_until = X, with X being the timestep before cm_startyear ist. Example: cm_startyear = 2045 --> no_ghgprices_land_until = 2040

flohump

scenario_config_coupled looks now fine from MAgPIE side

- introduce startgroup "remindinput" for scenarios that are required to update MAgPIE intputs in REMIND - remove choice of impact scenarios for MAgPIE, because climate change impacts are switches off by `nocc_hist` (see remindmodel#1920 (review))

laurinks and others added 4 commits December 9, 2024 10:34

Update ScenarioMIP config files in line with internal protocol v4

c525901

Corrections to SMIP config

a025214

Corrections of SMIP configs

60d1ebb

Merge branch 'develop' into SMIP-config-update

dbb2125

laurinks marked this pull request as ready for review December 9, 2024 11:42

laurinks added 2 commits December 9, 2024 15:09

Update startyear and fixing for M scenarios

4837f39

Add ScenarioMIP configs to CHANGELOG

65fc799

laurinks requested review from flohump, LaviniaBaumstark and dklein-pik December 9, 2024 14:30

flohump requested changes Dec 9, 2024

View reviewed changes

laurinks added 3 commits December 9, 2024 16:10

Remove rcp setting in coupling config as it is not needed and can be …

69bf476

…safely removed

Add variants of VLHO with NPI settings in MAgPIE

b7c2265

Correct no_ghgprices_land_until in couling config

c21ed18

laurinks requested a review from flohump December 9, 2024 16:36

flohump approved these changes Dec 9, 2024

View reviewed changes

laurinks added 2 commits December 9, 2024 23:04

Adjust CESMkups in ScenarioMIP config

c0446f5

Update near-term CO2 price assumptions

2ed09e6

laurinks merged commit 5f1b5c7 into remindmodel:develop Dec 10, 2024
2 checks passed

laurinks deleted the SMIP-config-update branch December 10, 2024 16:27

dklein-pik mentioned this pull request Jan 13, 2025

MAgPIE coupling: update scenario config #1945

Merged

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Update ScenarioMIP config files in line with internal protocol v4 #1920

Update ScenarioMIP config files in line with internal protocol v4 #1920

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024 •

edited

Loading

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024 •

edited

Loading

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024 •

edited

Loading

flohump left a comment •

edited

Loading

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024

flohump left a comment

Update ScenarioMIP config files in line with internal protocol v4 #1920

Update ScenarioMIP config files in line with internal protocol v4 #1920

Conversation

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024 • edited Loading

Purpose of this PR

Type of change

Checklist:

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024 • edited Loading

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024 • edited Loading

flohump left a comment • edited Loading

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024

flohump left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024 •

edited

Loading

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024 •

edited

Loading

laurinks commented Dec 9, 2024 •

edited

Loading

flohump left a comment •

edited

Loading