[DRAFT] Version 2 Features Implementation #4
Conversation
WalkthroughThis pull request introduces significant enhancements to the MAWAQIT Alexa skill, focusing on expanding functionality across multiple locales. Key additions include new intent handlers for favorite Adhan reciter selection, random Hadith retrieval, and audio player management. The changes span interaction models, language support, and backend logic, with a particular emphasis on improving user experience through more dynamic and personalized interactions. Changes
Sequence DiagramsequenceDiagram
participant User
participant AlexaSkill
participant AdhanReciterService
participant HadithService
User->>AlexaSkill: Request Favorite Adhan Reciter
AlexaSkill->>User: Prompt to Choose Reciter
User->>AlexaSkill: Select Reciter
AlexaSkill->>AdhanReciterService: Save Preference
AdhanReciterService-->>AlexaSkill: Confirmation
AlexaSkill->>User: Confirm Selection
User->>AlexaSkill: Request Random Hadith
AlexaSkill->>HadithService: Fetch Hadith
HadithService-->>AlexaSkill: Return Hadith
AlexaSkill->>User: Read Hadith
Poem
Tip CodeRabbit's docstrings feature is now available as part of our Early Access Program! Simply use the command Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 17
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (12)
lambda/interceptors.js (4)
91-97: Unnecessary use of 'async' in 'LocalizationInterceptor'The
processmethod is declared asasyncbut does not contain anyawaitstatements. Consider removing theasynckeyword if asynchronous operations are not utilized within the method.
94-96: Clarify conditional logic in 'LocalizationInterceptor'The condition
if(isValidRequestType(requestType))checks for request types where localization should be skipped. Consider renaming the functionisValidRequestTypetoshouldSkipLocalizationor inverting the condition to improve code readability.
134-140: Update comment to reflect interceptor's purposeThe comment inside the
ifblock mentions localization, which may not align with the purpose of theSavePersistenceAttributesToSessioninterceptor. Update the comment to accurately reflect that persistence attributes should not be saved when the skill is disabled.
190-192: Function name 'isValidRequestType' may be misleadingThe function
isValidRequestTypereturnstruefor request types where processing should be skipped. Consider renaming it toshouldSkipProcessingorisExcludedRequestTypeto better convey its purpose.lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (1)
659-659: Specify radix parameter inparseIntto avoid unexpected resultsWhen using
parseInt, it's best practice to specify the radix parameter to prevent unexpected behavior due to different number bases.Apply this diff:
-const adhaanReciter = adhaanRecitation[parseInt(favouriteReciter) - 1]; +const adhaanReciter = adhaanRecitation[parseInt(favouriteReciter, 10) - 1];lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js (1)
15-18: Fix operator precedence in canHandle methodThe parentheses around the startsWith check are unnecessary and might be confusing.
canHandle(handlerInput) { - return ( - Alexa.getRequestType(handlerInput.requestEnvelope).startsWith("PlaybackController") - ); + return Alexa.getRequestType(handlerInput.requestEnvelope).startsWith("PlaybackController"); },lambda/datasources.js (2)
114-138: Add input validation in getMetadataThe function assumes all required attributes exist and are valid.
const getMetadata = (handlerInput, title) => { + if (!handlerInput || !title) { + throw new Error("Missing required parameters in getMetadata"); + } const requestAttributes = handlerInput.attributesManager.getRequestAttributes(); + if (!requestAttributes) { + throw new Error("Request attributes not available"); + } let albumArtImage = requestAttributes.t("logoUrl"); + if (!albumArtImage) { + albumArtImage = "default_logo_url"; // Add a default fallback + } let metadata = { title: title, subtitle: requestAttributes.t("skillName"),
110-112: Add JSDoc documentation for getDataSourceForAdhaanReciterThe function lacks documentation about its parameters and return value.
+/** + * Generates data source for adhaan reciter list + * @param {Object} handlerInput - The Alexa skill handler input + * @param {Array} adhaanRecitation - List of available adhaan recitations + * @returns {Promise<Object>} Data source for the APL template + */ const getDataSourceForAdhaanReciter = async (handlerInput, adhaanRecitation) => { return getDataSourceforMosqueList(handlerInput, adhaanRecitation, "titleForAdhaanReciterList"); };lambda/prompts/en_US.js (1)
49-53: Ensure consistent user experience across touch and voice interactions.The prompts effectively guide users through both voice and touch interactions for selecting adhan recitations. However, consider adding validation feedback when users make their selection to confirm their choice before finalizing it.
adhanReciterPrompt: `Which recitation would you like to set as favourite for the adhan? You can choose between %s. You can choose by saying the number associated with the recitation `, +adhanReciterConfirmationPrompt: `You've selected %s. Is this correct? Say yes to confirm or no to choose again.`, adhanReciterErrorPrompt: `Sorry, I couldn't find any recitations for the adhan. Please try again.`, adhanReciterSuccessPrompt: `Perfect, %s is now your favorite recitation for the adhan! `,lambda/index.js (1)
46-54: Enhance error handling for directive service failuresWhile logging the error is good, consider providing a graceful fallback for users when the directive service fails.
async handle(handlerInput) { const { attributesManager } = handlerInput; const requestAttributes = attributesManager.getRequestAttributes(); await helperFunctions .callDirectiveService(handlerInput, requestAttributes.t("welcomePrompt")) .catch((error) => { console.log("Error while calling directive service: ", error); + // Provide a graceful fallback response + handlerInput.responseBuilder.speak(requestAttributes.t("welcomePrompt")); }); return await helperFunctions.checkForPersistenceData(handlerInput); }interactionModels/de-DE.json (1)
243-250: Add sample utterances for audio control intentsConsider adding German sample utterances for AMAZON.ResumeIntent and AMAZON.PauseIntent to improve voice interaction.
{ "name": "AMAZON.ResumeIntent", - "samples": [] + "samples": [ + "weiter", + "fortsetzen", + "weitermachen", + "fortfahren" + ] }, { "name": "AMAZON.PauseIntent", - "samples": [] + "samples": [ + "pause", + "pausieren", + "anhalten", + "unterbrechen" + ] }interactionModels/en-US.json (1)
293-298: Add sample utterances for audio control intentsConsider adding sample utterances for AMAZON.PauseIntent and AMAZON.ResumeIntent to improve voice interaction.
{ "name": "AMAZON.PauseIntent", - "samples": [] + "samples": [ + "pause", + "pause the audio", + "stop playing", + "pause playback" + ] }, { "name": "AMAZON.ResumeIntent", - "samples": [] + "samples": [ + "resume", + "continue", + "continue playing", + "resume playback" + ] }
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (20)
interactionModels/de-DE.json(4 hunks)interactionModels/en-AU.json(0 hunks)interactionModels/en-CA.json(0 hunks)interactionModels/en-GB.json(0 hunks)interactionModels/en-IN.json(0 hunks)interactionModels/en-US.json(6 hunks)interactionModels/fr-CA.json(0 hunks)interactionModels/fr-FR.json(17 hunks)lambda/aplDocuments/mosqueListApl.json(1 hunks)lambda/datasources.js(3 hunks)lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js(1 hunks)lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js(4 hunks)lambda/handlers/touchHandler.js(3 hunks)lambda/helperFunctions.js(3 hunks)lambda/index.js(3 hunks)lambda/interceptors.js(6 hunks)lambda/languageStrings.js(2 hunks)lambda/prompts/de_DE.js(1 hunks)lambda/prompts/en_US.js(1 hunks)lambda/prompts/fr_FR.js(1 hunks)
💤 Files with no reviewable changes (5)
- interactionModels/en-CA.json
- interactionModels/en-IN.json
- interactionModels/fr-CA.json
- interactionModels/en-AU.json
- interactionModels/en-GB.json
🧰 Additional context used
🪛 Biome (1.9.4)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js
[error] 319-319: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
lambda/interceptors.js
[error] 40-40: Change to an optional chain.
Unsafe fix: Change to an optional chain.
(lint/complexity/useOptionalChain)
🔇 Additional comments (13)
lambda/interceptors.js (1)
30-31: Approve addition of async and response check in 'AddDirectiveResponseInterceptor'
The change to make the process method asynchronous and to add a check for undefined response improves the robustness of the code by preventing potential runtime errors.
lambda/languageStrings.js (2)
3-3: Addition of German language support
The import statement for de_DE is correctly added, enabling German language prompts.
13-13: Exporting 'de-DE' mapping
The mapping for 'de-DE' is correctly added to the exports, enabling language support for German users.
lambda/aplDocuments/mosqueListApl.json (1)
32-32: Addition of title to 'SendEvent' arguments
Including "${payload.imageListData.title}" in the arguments array provides additional context to the event handler, which can enhance user interaction handling.
lambda/prompts/en_US.js (1)
48-48: LGTM!
The formatting change maintains consistency with other prompts.
lambda/index.js (3)
24-36: LGTM: Import statements are properly structured
The new imports for audio-related handlers and favorite adhaan reciter functionality are well-organized and align with the Version 2 feature requirements.
Line range hint 192-208: LGTM: Handler chain is properly ordered
The new audio and adhaan reciter handlers are correctly positioned in the chain, with audio handlers having appropriate precedence.
216-219: LGTM: Interceptors are properly ordered
The interceptor chain is well-organized with logging, localization, and persistence interceptors in the correct order.
interactionModels/de-DE.json (1)
281-283: LGTM: Prayer name formatting is consistent
The apostrophe usage in prayer names has been standardized correctly.
Also applies to: 292-294
interactionModels/en-US.json (1)
162-165: LGTM: Sample utterances are well-defined
The new sample utterances for NextPrayerTimeIntent provide good coverage of natural language variations.
interactionModels/fr-FR.json (2)
323-328: LGTM: Built-in Alexa intents
The addition of AMAZON.ResumeIntent and AMAZON.PauseIntent with empty samples is correct as these are built-in Alexa intents that handle standard pause/resume commands.
390-390: Verify apostrophe handling in "isha'a"
While adding this synonym improves voice recognition, verify that the apostrophe in "isha'a" is properly handled by Alexa's speech recognition system.
✅ Verification successful
Apostrophe in "isha'a" is safe to use
The search results show that apostrophes are already successfully used throughout the interaction models:
- In French (fr-FR) for contractions like "l'heure", "d'aujourd'hui"
- In English (en-US) for contractions like "I'm", "don't" and prayer name "Jumu'ah"
- In German (de-DE) for prayer names including "Isha'a" itself
The apostrophe in "isha'a" follows the same pattern as other prayer names and contractions that are already working in the interaction models, making it a safe addition.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check if other intents in the model use apostrophes successfully
rg -l "'" interactionModels/
Length of output: 116
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check actual usage of apostrophes in interaction models
rg -A 2 -B 2 "'" interactionModels/*.json
Length of output: 10494
lambda/helperFunctions.js (1)
85-87: Verify impact of removing welcome prompt
The removal of the welcome prompt parameter might affect the user experience. Ensure this change aligns with the intended interaction flow.
✅ Verification successful
Removal of welcome prompt parameter is safe
The welcome message is still properly handled through the main index.js using callDirectiveService with the localized welcome prompt. The removal of the welcome prompt parameter from getPrayerTimingsForMosque and getListOfMosque functions doesn't impact the user experience as the welcome message is delivered separately through the directive service.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check usage of welcome prompts across the codebase
rg "welcomePrompt|welcome_prompt" --type js
Length of output: 332
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check the implementation of getPrayerTimingsForMosque and getListOfMosque functions
ast-grep --pattern 'function getPrayerTimingsForMosque($_,$_,$_) { $$$ }'
ast-grep --pattern 'function getListOfMosque($_,$_) { $$$ }'
# Check for any other welcome message handling
rg "welcomePrompt" -B 2 -A 2 --type js
Length of output: 2035
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js (1)
6-9: Add logging toAudioPlayerEventHandlerfor better debuggingCurrently, the
AudioPlayerEventHandlerreturns a response without any logging. Adding logging statements can help in debugging audio player events.Consider adding a console log in the
handlemethod:async handle(handlerInput) { + const audioPlayerEvent = Alexa.getRequestType(handlerInput.requestEnvelope); + console.log("Audio Player Event:", audioPlayerEvent); return handlerInput.responseBuilder.getResponse(); },lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (1)
562-640: Handle potential errors in translation serviceIn
FavoriteAdhaanReciterStartedHandler, the translation ofadhaan.primaryTextmay fail if the translation service encounters an error. This could break the skill's flow.Consider adding error handling for the translation calls:
try { adhaan.primaryText = await helperFunctions.translateText( adhaan.primaryText, locale ); } catch (translationError) { console.log("Translation error:", translationError); // Fallback to original text if translation fails adhaan.primaryText = adhaan.primaryText; }
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (8)
interactionModels/en-US.json(6 hunks)interactionModels/fr-FR.json(17 hunks)lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js(1 hunks)lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js(4 hunks)lambda/helperFunctions.js(3 hunks)lambda/interceptors.js(6 hunks)lambda/prompts/de_DE.js(1 hunks)lambda/prompts/fr_FR.js(1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
- lambda/prompts/de_DE.js
🔇 Additional comments (16)
lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js (3)
47-55: Add handling for AMAZON.PauseIntent
The PauseIntent currently falls through to the default case. Consider adding specific handling to properly manage the pause action.
As previously suggested, apply this diff:
switch (intent) {
case "AMAZON.ResumeIntent":
return await intentHandler.PlayAdhanIntentHandler.handle(handlerInput);
+ case "AMAZON.PauseIntent":
+ return handlerInput.responseBuilder
+ .addAudioPlayerStopDirective()
+ .withShouldEndSession(false) // Allow resuming later
+ .getResponse();
default:
return handlerInput.responseBuilder
.addAudioPlayerStopDirective()
.withShouldEndSession(true)
.getResponse();
}21-32: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add error handling for PlayAdhanIntentHandler
In PlaybackCommandHandler, the playback commands delegate to PlayAdhanIntentHandler without error handling. Wrapping the call in a try-catch block can handle unexpected errors gracefully.
Apply this diff to add error handling:
switch (playback) {
case "PlaybackController.PlayCommandIssued":
case "PlaybackController.NextCommandIssued":
case "PlaybackController.PreviousCommandIssued":
- return await intentHandler.PlayAdhanIntentHandler.handle(handlerInput);
+ try {
+ return await intentHandler.PlayAdhanIntentHandler.handle(handlerInput);
+ } catch (error) {
+ console.error("Error in PlayAdhanIntentHandler:", error);
+ return handlerInput.responseBuilder
+ .speak("Sorry, there was an error playing the adhaan.")
+ .withShouldEndSession(true)
+ .getResponse();
+ }
default:
return handlerInput.responseBuilder
.addAudioPlayerStopDirective()
.withShouldEndSession(true)
.getResponse();
}38-42:
Fix logical operator precedence in canHandle method
In AudioIntentHandler, the condition in the canHandle method may produce unexpected results due to operator precedence. Enclosing the || conditions within parentheses ensures correct evaluation.
Apply this diff to fix the logical operator precedence:
return (
Alexa.getRequestType(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "IntentRequest" &&
- Alexa.getIntentName(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "AMAZON.ResumeIntent" ||
- Alexa.getIntentName(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "AMAZON.PauseIntent"
+ (Alexa.getIntentName(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "AMAZON.ResumeIntent" ||
+ Alexa.getIntentName(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "AMAZON.PauseIntent")
);lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (2)
666-668:
Initialize persistentAttributes before assignment
Ensure that sessionAttributes.persistentAttributes is initialized before assigning favouriteAdhaan to prevent potential runtime errors.
Apply this diff to initialize persistentAttributes if undefined:
+ if (!sessionAttributes.persistentAttributes) {
+ sessionAttributes.persistentAttributes = {};
+ }
sessionAttributes.persistentAttributes.favouriteAdhaan = adhaanReciter;314-336:
Ensure persistentAttributes is defined before use
In PlayAdhanIntentHandler, persistentAttributes may be undefined if not previously set. Accessing properties on an undefined object can cause runtime errors.
Modify the code to check if persistentAttributes and persistentAttributes.favouriteAdhaan are defined:
const { persistentAttributes } = sessionAttributes;
let audioName = "Adhaan";
let audioUrl = prayerName === "0" ? adhaanRecitation[0].fajrUrl : adhaanRecitation[0].otherUrl;
- if(persistentAttributes?.favouriteAdhaan){
+ if (persistentAttributes && persistentAttributes.favouriteAdhaan) {
const { primaryText } = persistentAttributes.favouriteAdhaan;
audioName = primaryText;
audioUrl = prayerName === "0" ? persistentAttributes.favouriteAdhaan.fajrUrl : persistentAttributes.favouriteAdhaan.otherUrl;
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
lambda/prompts/fr_FR.js (1)
52-57: Verify the accuracy and naturalness of French translations
Please ensure that the French translations for the new prompts accurately reflect the intended meanings and are idiomatic.
Consider consulting a native French speaker or a professional translator to review the following prompts:
adhanReciterPromptadhanReciterErrorPromptadhanReciterSuccessPromptchooseAdhaanByTouchPrompt
lambda/interceptors.js (1)
189-193:
Correct typo in function name SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVaraibleFromAwsSsm
The function name contains a typo: "Varaible" should be "Variable". Ensure all references are updated accordingly.
Apply this diff to fix the typo:
- const SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVaraibleFromAwsSsm = {
+ const SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVariableFromAwsSsm = {And update the export statement:
module.exports = {
LogResponseInterceptor,
LogRequestInterceptor,
LocalizationInterceptor,
SavePersistenceAttributesToSession,
AddDirectiveResponseInterceptor,
- SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVaraibleFromAwsSsm
+ SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVariableFromAwsSsm
};interactionModels/en-US.json (4)
Line range hint 162-177: LGTM! Good variety of sample utterances
The sample utterances provide comprehensive coverage of different ways users might ask about prayer times.
451-459: LGTM! Clear elicitation prompt
The prompt is clear and appropriate for number input.
292-298: Verify audio player implementation
The addition of AMAZON.PauseIntent and AMAZON.ResumeIntent suggests audio playback functionality.
Let's verify the audio player implementation:
✅ Verification successful
Audio player implementation is properly implemented
The codebase has a complete audio player implementation with:
- Dedicated
AudioPlayerEventHandlerfor handling audio player events AudioIntentHandlerspecifically handling AMAZON.PauseIntent and AMAZON.ResumeIntent- Proper audio playback directives (.addAudioPlayerPlayDirective and .addAudioPlayerStopDirective)
- Integration with the skill's main functionality for playing Adhan (call to prayer)
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for audio player handler implementation
ast-grep --pattern 'class $_ {
$$$
handle$_(handlerInput) {
$$$
AMAZON.$_Intent
$$$
}
$$$
}'
Length of output: 114
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for audio player related handlers and implementations
rg -i "pause|resume|audioplayer" -A 5 -B 5
# Also check for audio player interface declaration
rg -i "audioPlayer" -A 2 -B 2
Length of output: 11014
38-54: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add input validation for reciter selection
The favouriteReciter slot uses AMAZON.NUMBER without bounds checking, which could allow invalid selections.
Let's verify the available reciter options:
Consider adding validation in the handler to ensure the selected number corresponds to a valid reciter option.
interactionModels/fr-FR.json (2)
331-343: LGTM! Well-localized French utterances
The French sample utterances are properly localized and provide good coverage.
522-525: LGTM! Properly translated prompt
The elicitation prompt is correctly translated to French.
lambda/helperFunctions.js (3)
466-489: LGTM! Well-implemented progressive response handling
The implementation includes proper error handling and follows best practices.
491-493: LGTM! Correct Promise implementation
The sleep function is properly implemented using Promise and setTimeout.
85-87: Consider user experience impact
Removing the welcome prompt might affect the user experience for first-time users.
Let's check if the welcome prompt is handled elsewhere:
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (1)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (1)
317-323: Add fallback handling for audio URL selectionThe logic for selecting the audio URL is correct but could be more robust with default values and destructuring.
Consider this refactor:
-let audioName = "Adhaan"; -let audioUrl = prayerName === "0"? adhaanRecitation[0].fajrUrl : adhaanRecitation[0].otherUrl; -if(persistentAttributes?.favouriteAdhaan){ - const { primaryText } = persistentAttributes.favouriteAdhaan; - audioName = primaryText; - audioUrl = prayerName === "0"? persistentAttributes.favouriteAdhaan.fajrUrl : persistentAttributes.favouriteAdhaan.otherUrl; -} +const defaultReciter = adhaanRecitation[0]; +const favoriteReciter = persistentAttributes?.favouriteAdhaan; +const selectedReciter = favoriteReciter || defaultReciter; +const audioName = selectedReciter.primaryText || "Adhaan"; +const audioUrl = prayerName === "0" ? selectedReciter.fajrUrl : selectedReciter.otherUrl;
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (1)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js(4 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🪛 Biome (1.9.4)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js
[error] 660-660: isNaN is unsafe. It attempts a type coercion. Use Number.isNaN instead.
See the MDN documentation for more details.
Unsafe fix: Use Number.isNaN instead.
(lint/suspicious/noGlobalIsNan)
🔇 Additional comments (1)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (1)
671-673:
Initialize persistentAttributes before assignment
This is a duplicate of a previously identified issue where persistentAttributes needs to be initialized before use.
Co-authored-by: coderabbitai[bot] <136622811+coderabbitai[bot]@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: coderabbitai[bot] <136622811+coderabbitai[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 7
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (4)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (1)
658-658: Specify radix parameter inparseIntWhen using
parseInt, it's recommended to specify the radix to avoid unexpected results due to different number formats.Suggested fix:
- const reciterIndex = parseInt(favouriteReciter) - 1; + const reciterIndex = parseInt(favouriteReciter, 10) - 1;lambda/handlers/apiHandler.js (1)
73-90: LGTM with suggestions for error handling enhancement.The implementation follows the established pattern in the codebase for API calls. However, consider enhancing the error handling to provide more specific error messages for different failure scenarios.
const getRandomHadith = async (lang = "ar") => { const config = getConfig("get", `/hadith/random?lang=${lang}`, "2.0"); console.log("Config: ", JSON.stringify(config, null, 2).replace(/Bearer \w+/g, "Bearer ****")); return await axios .request(config) .then((response) => { console.log("Hadith: ", JSON.stringify(response.data)); if (!response || !response.data || !response.data.text) { - throw "Received Empty Response"; + throw new Error("No hadith text found in response"); } return response.data.text; }) .catch((error) => { console.log("Error while fetching Hadith: ", error); + if (error.response) { + switch (error.response.status) { + case 404: + throw new Error("No hadith found for the specified language"); + case 429: + throw new Error("Rate limit exceeded"); + default: + throw new Error(`API error: ${error.response.status}`); + } + } throw error; }); }lambda/helperFunctions.js (1)
466-489: Consider enhancing error handling with specific error types.While the implementation is good, error handling could be more specific.
Consider this enhancement:
async function callDirectiveService(handlerInput, speakOutput) { console.log("Call Directive Service"); try { const requestEnvelope = handlerInput.requestEnvelope; const directiveServiceClient = handlerInput.serviceClientFactory.getDirectiveServiceClient(); const requestId = requestEnvelope.request.requestId; const directive = { header: { requestId, }, directive: { type: 'VoicePlayer.Speak', speech: speakOutput, }, }; return await directiveServiceClient.enqueue(directive); } catch (error) { - console.error('Error calling directive service:', error); + if (error.name === 'ServiceError') { + console.error('Service error in directive service:', error.message); + } else if (error.name === 'DirectiveServiceError') { + console.error('Directive service error:', error.message); + } else { + console.error('Unexpected error in directive service:', error); + } // Continue skill flow without progressive response return Promise.resolve(); } }lambda/index.js (1)
218-221: Consider the order of request interceptorsThe sequence of request interceptors can affect their functionality. It might be beneficial to place
SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVariableFromAwsSsmbeforeLocalizationInterceptorif localization depends on environment variables set by it.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (12)
interactionModels/de-DE.json(4 hunks)interactionModels/en-US.json(6 hunks)interactionModels/fr-FR.json(17 hunks)lambda/handlers/apiHandler.js(3 hunks)lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js(1 hunks)lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js(4 hunks)lambda/helperFunctions.js(4 hunks)lambda/index.js(3 hunks)lambda/interceptors.js(5 hunks)lambda/prompts/de_DE.js(1 hunks)lambda/prompts/en_US.js(1 hunks)lambda/prompts/fr_FR.js(1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (2)
- lambda/prompts/en_US.js
- interactionModels/de-DE.json
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js (1)
Learnt from: ijaz26
PR: mawaqit/alexa#4
File: lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js:22-27
Timestamp: 2024-12-12T13:46:45.984Z
Learning: In the file `lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js`, the `PlaybackCommandHandler` delegates to `PlayAdhanIntentHandler` without additional error handling, and this is acceptable.
🪛 Biome (1.9.4)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js
[error] 695-698: This block statement doesn't serve any purpose and can be safely removed.
Standalone block statements without any block-level declarations are redundant in JavaScript and can be removed to simplify the code.
Safe fix: Remove redundant block.
(lint/complexity/noUselessLoneBlockStatements)
🔇 Additional comments (19)
lambda/prompts/de_DE.js (1)
54-54:
Translate 'hadithErrorPrompt' to German
The prompt for 'hadithErrorPrompt' is in English. Please translate it to German to maintain consistency and provide a seamless user experience.
Suggested fix:
- hadithErrorPrompt: `Sorry, I couldn't find any hadiths. Please try again.`,
+ hadithErrorPrompt: `Entschuldigung, ich konnte keine Hadithe finden. Bitte versuchen Sie es erneut.`,lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (1)
670-672:
Initialize 'persistentAttributes' before assignment
Ensure that sessionAttributes.persistentAttributes is initialized before assigning favouriteAdhaan to prevent potential runtime errors.
Suggested fix:
+ sessionAttributes.persistentAttributes = sessionAttributes.persistentAttributes || {};
sessionAttributes.persistentAttributes.favouriteAdhaan = adhaanReciter;lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js (1)
40-44:
Fix logical operator precedence in canHandle method
The current condition may not behave as intended due to operator precedence. To correctly check if the request is an IntentRequest and the intent name is either AMAZON.ResumeIntent or AMAZON.PauseIntent, we should adjust the parentheses.
Suggested fix:
return (
Alexa.getRequestType(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "IntentRequest" &&
- Alexa.getIntentName(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "AMAZON.ResumeIntent" ||
- Alexa.getIntentName(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "AMAZON.PauseIntent"
+ (
+ Alexa.getIntentName(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "AMAZON.ResumeIntent" ||
+ Alexa.getIntentName(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "AMAZON.PauseIntent"
+ )
);lambda/interceptors.js (2)
30-31: LGTM! Improved code robustness.
Good improvements:
- Added null check for response
- Updated to use optional chaining for safer property access
Also applies to: 40-40
190-192: LGTM! Good function extraction.
The isValidRequestType function effectively consolidates the request type validation logic.
interactionModels/en-US.json (3)
109-111: LGTM! Natural language samples.
The fallback samples are well-chosen and follow natural conversation patterns.
162-165: LGTM! Comprehensive prayer time query samples.
The new samples provide good coverage for different ways users might ask about prayer times.
292-299: LGTM! Proper implementation of media control intents.
The AMAZON.PauseIntent and AMAZON.ResumeIntent are correctly implemented as built-in intents.
interactionModels/fr-FR.json (2)
73-78: LGTM! Natural French translations.
The French samples are well-translated and maintain natural language patterns.
Also applies to: 97-101
331-344: LGTM! Well-localized reciter selection intent.
The French implementation provides good coverage with natural language samples.
lambda/helperFunctions.js (2)
85-87: LGTM! Simplified persistence check flow.
The changes streamline the function by removing unnecessary parameters.
Line range hint 452-465: LGTM! Improved language handling.
The function now properly handles language codes with better error management.
lambda/index.js (7)
193-195: Ensure correct ordering of audio handlers
The AudioPlayerEventHandler, PlaybackCommandHandler, and AudioIntentHandler have been added. Verify that these handlers are ordered correctly in the handler chain to prioritize specific intent handling and prevent conflicts.
202-202: Verify the placement of HadithIntentHandler
Confirm that the HadithIntentHandler is correctly placed in the request handler chain to ensure it processes HadithIntent without interference from other handlers.
210-210: Ensure AdhaanRecitationTouchEventHandler is correctly implemented
The AdhaanRecitationTouchEventHandler has been added to handle touch events. Verify that it is properly implemented and integrated with the skill's touch interface.
42-44: Verify the necessity of handling "LaunchIntent"
In the LaunchRequestHandler, you are checking for an IntentRequest with the intent name "LaunchIntent". Typically, the skill launch is handled by "LaunchRequest". Ensure that "LaunchIntent" is defined in your interaction model and that this check is required.
Run the following script to confirm if "LaunchIntent" exists in your interaction models:
✅ Verification successful
Let me check the interaction model files to understand how this LaunchIntent is defined and used.
The handling of "LaunchIntent" is correctly implemented
The LaunchIntent is properly defined in all interaction models with appropriate utterances for launching the skill in different languages (e.g., "open mawaqit", "launch mawaqit", etc.). The code's dual handling of both LaunchRequest and LaunchIntent is intentional and correct, allowing users to start the skill either through the default launch phrase or through these custom launch utterances.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Search for "LaunchIntent" in the interaction model files.
# Test: Check for the definition of "LaunchIntent".
# Expect: Find intent definitions if it exists.
rg '"name":\s*"LaunchIntent"' interactionModels/
Length of output: 680
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Get a sample of the LaunchIntent definition from one of the interaction models
cat interactionModels/en-US.json | jq '.interactionModel.languageModel.intents[] | select(.name == "LaunchIntent")'
# Check if there are any sample utterances or other handlers using LaunchIntent
rg -A 5 '"LaunchIntent"' interactionModels/
Length of output: 3880
47-54: Unnecessary await with checkForPersistenceData
You're using await with helperFunctions.checkForPersistenceData(handlerInput);. If checkForPersistenceData is not an asynchronous function returning a promise, the await keyword is unnecessary and should be removed to avoid potential delays.
Run the following script to verify if checkForPersistenceData is asynchronous:
205-207: Confirm the addition of new intent handlers
The handlers SelectMosqueIntentAfterSelectingMosqueHandler, FavoriteAdhaanReciterStartedHandler, and FavoriteAdhaanReciterIntentHandler have been added. Ensure these handlers are properly implemented and their corresponding intents are defined in the interaction model.
Run the following script to check for the intents:
✅ Verification successful
Let me verify the implementation of these handlers.
Let me check if these handlers are properly registered in the skill builder.
Let me check the rest of the skill builder registration to see if our new handlers are included.
All handlers are properly implemented and registered
Based on the verification results:
- All three handlers (
SelectMosqueIntentAfterSelectingMosqueHandler,FavoriteAdhaanReciterStartedHandler, andFavoriteAdhaanReciterIntentHandler) are fully implemented inlambda/handlers/intentHandler.js - The handlers are properly registered in the skill builder
- The
FavoriteAdhaanReciterIntentis defined in both en-US and fr-FR interaction models - While
SelectMosqueIntentAfterSelectingMosqueintent is not found in interaction models, it's because it reuses the existingSelectMosqueIntentwith a specific slot value condition in itscanHandlemethod
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Verify that the new intents are defined.
# Test: Search for intent definitions.
# Expect: Find definitions of the intents.
rg '"name":\s*"SelectMosqueIntentAfterSelectingMosque"' interactionModels/
rg '"name":\s*"FavoriteAdhaanReciterStartedIntent"' interactionModels/
rg '"name":\s*"FavoriteAdhaanReciterIntent"' interactionModels/
Length of output: 527
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check for handler implementations
ast-grep --pattern 'const SelectMosqueIntentAfterSelectingMosqueHandler = {
$$$
}'
ast-grep --pattern 'const FavoriteAdhaanReciterStartedHandler = {
$$$
}'
ast-grep --pattern 'const FavoriteAdhaanReciterIntentHandler = {
$$$
}'
# Also check if these handlers are properly registered
rg -A 5 "exports.handler = Alexa.SkillBuilders" lambda/
Length of output: 14602
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check if the new handlers are registered in the skill builder
rg -B 5 -A 15 'exports.handler = Alexa.SkillBuilders' lambda/index.js
Length of output: 830
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Get more lines of the skill builder registration
rg -B 5 -A 30 'exports.handler = Alexa.SkillBuilders' lambda/index.js
Length of output: 1304
10-10: Verify the correct import of SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVariableFromAwsSsm
Ensure that SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVariableFromAwsSsm is correctly exported and spelled consistently across the codebase.
Run the following script to check its export:
✅ Verification successful
SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVariableFromAwsSsm is correctly defined and used
The interceptor is properly defined in lambda/interceptors.js as an object and is correctly imported and used in lambda/index.js. The naming is consistent across all occurrences in the codebase.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Verify that `SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVariableFromAwsSsm` is exported from 'interceptors.js'.
# Test: Search for the export statement. Expect: Find the export of the interceptor.
rg 'exports\.SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVariableFromAwsSsm' lambda/interceptors.js
Length of output: 80
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's try different search patterns to find this function/class
# Search for the exact name in all files
rg "SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVariableFromAwsSsm" -A 3
# Search for similar names (in case of typos)
rg -i "set.*api.*keys.*environment.*ssm"
# Look for exports containing similar patterns
rg "exports\.(Set|set).*SSM"
# Use ast-grep to find function/class declarations with similar name
ast-grep --pattern 'function SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVariableFromAwsSsm($_) { $$$ }'
ast-grep --pattern 'class SetApiKeysAsEnvironmentVariableFromAwsSsm { $$$ }'
Length of output: 1696
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (7)
lambda/prompts/fr_FR.js (1)
51-51: Use non-breaking space before question markIn French typography, a non-breaking space should be used before question marks. Consider using
\u00A0(non-breaking space) instead of a regular space.- doYouNeedAnythingElsePrompt: " Voulez-vous autre chose ?", + doYouNeedAnythingElsePrompt: " Voulez-vous autre chose\u00A0?",lambda/handlers/apiHandler.js (1)
72-89: Enhance error handling for specific HTTP status codes.While the implementation is solid, consider adding specific error handling for common HTTP status codes (e.g., 404, 429) to provide more informative error messages.
const getRandomHadith = async (lang = "ar") => { const config = getConfig("get", `/hadith/random?lang=${lang}`, "2.0"); console.log("Config: ", JSON.stringify(config, null, 2).replace(/Bearer \w+/g, "Bearer ****")); return await axios .request(config) .then((response) => { console.log("Hadith: ", JSON.stringify(response.data)); if (!response || !response.data || !response.data.text) { throw "Received Empty Response"; } return response.data.text; }) .catch((error) => { console.log("Error while fetching Hadith: ", error); + if (error.response) { + switch (error.response.status) { + case 404: + throw "Hadith not found"; + case 429: + throw "Rate limit exceeded"; + default: + throw error; + } + } throw error; }); }lambda/helperFunctions.js (2)
Line range hint
32-38: Consider type validation for createDirectivePayload parameters.The function could benefit from basic type validation for its parameters.
const createDirectivePayload = (aplDocument, dataSources = {}, type = "Alexa.Presentation.APL.RenderDocument") => { + if (!aplDocument || typeof aplDocument !== 'object') { + throw new Error('Invalid APL document'); + } + if (typeof dataSources !== 'object') { + throw new Error('Invalid dataSources'); + } return { type: type, token: uuidv4(), document: aplDocument, datasources: dataSources, }; };
506-512: Consider adding validation for time parameter.The function should validate the time parameter format.
const createDataSourceForPrayerTiming = (time) => { + if (!/^\d{2}:\d{2}$/.test(time)) { + console.warn('Invalid time format:', time); + return { "data": { "text": "00:00" } }; + } return { "data": { "text": time } } }lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (3)
317-339: Add error handling for audio URLsWhile the implementation looks good, consider adding validation for audio URLs to handle potential undefined or invalid URLs gracefully.
let audioUrl = prayerName === "0"? adhaanRecitation[0].fajrUrl : adhaanRecitation[0].otherUrl; +if (!audioUrl) { + console.error("Audio URL is undefined"); + return handlerInput.responseBuilder + .speak(requestAttributes.t("audioErrorPrompt")) + .withShouldEndSession(false) + .getResponse(); +}
565-643: Consider caching translated adhaan reciter namesThe translation of adhaan reciter names is performed every time the handler is called. Consider caching these translations to improve performance.
Consider implementing a translation cache:
const translationCache = new Map(); const getTranslatedText = async (text, locale) => { const cacheKey = `${text}_${locale}`; if (translationCache.has(cacheKey)) { return translationCache.get(cacheKey); } const translated = await helperFunctions.translateText(text, locale); translationCache.set(cacheKey, translated); return translated; };
645-686: Add persistence validation before savingConsider adding validation to ensure the persistence layer is available before attempting to save.
- await attributesManager.savePersistentAttributes(); + try { + await attributesManager.savePersistentAttributes(); + } catch (error) { + console.error("Failed to save persistent attributes:", error); + return responseBuilder + .speak(requestAttributes.t("saveErrorPrompt")) + .withShouldEndSession(false) + .getResponse(); + }
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (6)
lambda/aplDocuments/characterDisplayApl.json(1 hunks)lambda/handlers/apiHandler.js(2 hunks)lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js(8 hunks)lambda/helperFunctions.js(9 hunks)lambda/interceptors.js(5 hunks)lambda/prompts/fr_FR.js(1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
- lambda/interceptors.js
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
lambda/helperFunctions.js (1)
Learnt from: ijaz26
PR: mawaqit/alexa#4
File: lambda/helperFunctions.js:491-493
Timestamp: 2024-12-14T15:39:02.019Z
Learning: In `lambda/helperFunctions.js`, the `locale` parameter in the `splitLanguage` function will never be null, so input validation for `locale` is unnecessary.
🔇 Additional comments (12)
lambda/prompts/fr_FR.js (2)
52-56: LGTM! Well-implemented French translations
The new adhan reciter prompts are properly translated and maintain consistency with the existing localization style. The translations are natural and preserve the required format strings.
57-57: Translation looks good
The hadith error prompt is now properly translated to French, addressing the previous review comment.
lambda/aplDocuments/characterDisplayApl.json (1)
1-15: LGTM! Well-structured APL document.
The APL document is correctly configured for character display using APLT, with proper parameterization and a clean, minimalist design.
lambda/handlers/apiHandler.js (1)
107-107: LGTM! Export added correctly.
The new function is properly exported alongside existing functions.
lambda/helperFunctions.js (5)
9-9: LGTM! Required import added.
The APL document import is correctly added for character display functionality.
299-305: LGTM! Well-implemented character display check.
The function correctly checks for APLT support and adds the directive when available.
477-500: LGTM! Robust directive service implementation.
The implementation includes proper error handling and follows the progressive response pattern.
502-504: LGTM! Simple and effective language code extraction.
Based on the learnings from previous reviews, input validation is not required as the locale parameter will never be null.
530-534: LGTM! New functions properly exported.
All new functions are correctly added to the exports object.
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (3)
3-3: LGTM: Import statements are properly structured
The new imports align well with the added functionality for adhaan recitation and hadith features.
Also applies to: 5-10
699-702: Remove redundant block statement in catch block
The catch block contains a redundant block statement that should be removed.
721-724: LGTM: Exports are properly updated
All new handlers are correctly included in the module exports.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
🧹 Nitpick comments (2)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (2)
315-316: Consider moving the task name to a constantThe hardcoded task name
'amzn1.ask.skill.81a30fbf-496f-4aa4-a60b-9e35fb513506.PlayAdhaan'should be moved to a constant for better maintainability.+const PLAY_ADHAAN_TASK = 'amzn1.ask.skill.81a30fbf-496f-4aa4-a60b-9e35fb513506.PlayAdhaan'; + const PlayAdhanIntentHandler = { canHandle(handlerInput) { const request = handlerInput.requestEnvelope.request; return ( Alexa.getRequestType(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "IntentRequest" && Alexa.getIntentName(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "PlayAdhanIntent" || (Alexa.getRequestType(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "LaunchRequest" && request.task - && request.task.name === "amzn1.ask.skill.81a30fbf-496f-4aa4-a60b-9e35fb513506.PlayAdhaan") + && request.task.name === PLAY_ADHAAN_TASK) ); },
703-706: Consider enhancing hadith error handlingThe error handling could be improved by adding retry logic or fallback content.
- const hadith = await getRandomHadith(locale).catch((error) => { - console.log("Error in fetching hadith: ", error); - return requestAttributes.t("hadithErrorPrompt"); - }); + const hadith = await getRandomHadith(locale).catch(async (error) => { + console.log("Error in fetching hadith: ", error); + // Retry once with default language + if (locale !== 'en') { + try { + return await getRandomHadith('en'); + } catch (retryError) { + console.log("Error in retry: ", retryError); + } + } + return requestAttributes.t("hadithErrorPrompt"); + });
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (2)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js(8 hunks)lambda/index.js(3 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (1)
Learnt from: ijaz26
PR: mawaqit/alexa#4
File: lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js:22-27
Timestamp: 2024-12-12T13:46:45.984Z
Learning: In the file `lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js`, the `PlaybackCommandHandler` delegates to `PlayAdhanIntentHandler` without additional error handling, and this is acceptable.
🔇 Additional comments (8)
lambda/index.js (3)
10-10: LGTM: Well-organized imports and handler additions
The new imports are properly structured and organized by functionality. The naming conventions are consistent, and the handlers are appropriately grouped based on their responsibilities (intent handlers, touch handlers, and audio handlers).
Also applies to: 24-37
195-212: LGTM: Proper handler chain ordering
The new handlers are added in the correct order, with audio handlers placed appropriately before other handlers to ensure proper audio playback handling.
220-223: LGTM: Proper interceptor chain ordering
The interceptors are added in the correct order:
- Request logging
- Localization
- API key setup
- Session attributes persistence
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (5)
3-3: LGTM: Import changes align with new functionality
The import changes appropriately support the new adhaan recitation and hadith features.
Also applies to: 6-10
310-343: LGTM: Enhanced PlayAdhanIntentHandler with personalization
The handler now supports favorite adhaan selection and improves the audio player experience with metadata.
666-670: LGTM: Robust input validation
The handler properly validates the reciter index with appropriate error handling and user feedback.
725-728: LGTM: Export changes are complete
All new handlers are properly exported.
599-611: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve translation error handling
The catch block silently continues execution after a translation error, which could lead to untranslated content being displayed to users.
try {
adhaanRecitationList = await Promise.all(
adhaanRecitationList.map(async (adhaan) => {
adhaan.primaryText = await helperFunctions.translateText(
adhaan.primaryText,
locale
);
return adhaan;
})
);
} catch (error) {
console.log("Error in getting adhaan reciter list: ", error);
+ speechPrompt += requestAttributes.t("translationErrorPrompt");
+ adhaanRecitationList = adhaanRecitation; // Fallback to untranslated list
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 9
🧹 Nitpick comments (6)
skillManifest/skill.json (1)
495-501: Consider using more granular permission scopesThe skill requests broad location permissions:
alexa::devices:all:address:full:read: Provides full addressalexa::devices:all:geolocation:read: Provides precise locationConsider if more granular permissions would suffice:
alexa::devices:all:address:country_and_postal_code:read: If only country/postal code needed- Coarse location instead of precise geolocation
This would follow the principle of least privilege and potentially increase user trust.
skill-package/tasks/PlayAdhaan.1.json (1)
44-55: Improve request body documentationThe request body example is empty with a vague description "No Input required". This could be more informative.
Consider:
- Adding a more descriptive explanation of why no input is needed
- Documenting any optional parameters that might be supported in the future
- Adding schema validation to explicitly show that an empty object is expected
"requestBody": { "content": { "application/json": { + "schema": { + "type": "object", + "additionalProperties": false, + "description": "This endpoint requires no parameters as it simply triggers the Adhaan playback" + }, "examples": { "sampleInput": { - "description": "No Input required", + "description": "Simple trigger with no parameters required", "value": {} } } } } },lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (2)
569-647: Enhance APL error recovery in FavoriteAdhaanReciterStartedHandlerThe APL directive creation has error handling, but it could provide a better fallback experience.
Consider this improvement:
try { const dataSource = await getDataSourceForAdhaanReciter( handlerInput, adhaanRecitationList ); console.log("Data Source: ", JSON.stringify(dataSource)); const aplDirective = helperFunctions.createDirectivePayload( listApl, dataSource ); console.log("APL Directive: ", JSON.stringify(aplDirective)); responseBuilder.addDirective(aplDirective); speechPrompt += requestAttributes.t("chooseAdhaanByTouchPrompt"); } catch (error) { console.log("Error in creating APL Directive: ", error); + // Fallback to voice-only experience + speechPrompt += requestAttributes.t("chooseAdhaanByVoicePrompt"); }
715-728: Enhance logging in RoutinesTriggerHandlerThe handler logs the request but doesn't provide structured logging for easier debugging.
Improve logging structure:
handle(handlerInput) { const requestType = handlerInput.requestEnvelope.request.type; - console.log(`In RoutinesTriggerHandler : ${requestType}`); - console.log(JSON.stringify(handlerInput.requestEnvelope.request)); + console.log({ + handler: 'RoutinesTriggerHandler', + requestType, + timestamp: new Date().toISOString(), + request: handlerInput.requestEnvelope.request + }); return handlerInput.responseBuilder .getResponse(); }skill-package/skill.json (2)
359-361: Consider enabling automatic distributionThe skill is marked as available worldwide but has automatic distribution disabled. This might limit the skill's reach.
Consider enabling automatic distribution if the skill is ready for wider deployment, as it's marked as
isAvailableWorldwide: true.Also applies to: 362-362
378-394: Review Lambda function region configurationThe skill uses the same Lambda ARN for all regions, which might impact latency for users in different regions.
Consider deploying the Lambda function to multiple regions and configuring region-specific endpoints to reduce latency for users in different geographical locations.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (7)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js(8 hunks)lambda/index.js(3 hunks)skill-package/routines/triggers/PlayAdhaan/en-CA.json(1 hunks)skill-package/routines/triggers/PlayAdhaan/en-US.json(1 hunks)skill-package/skill.json(1 hunks)skill-package/tasks/PlayAdhaan.1.json(1 hunks)skillManifest/skill.json(9 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (1)
Learnt from: ijaz26
PR: mawaqit/alexa#4
File: lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js:22-27
Timestamp: 2024-12-12T13:46:45.984Z
Learning: In the file `lambda/handlers/audioPlayerHandler.js`, the `PlaybackCommandHandler` delegates to `PlayAdhanIntentHandler` without additional error handling, and this is acceptable.
🪛 checkov (3.2.334)
skill-package/tasks/PlayAdhaan.1.json
[HIGH] 1-89: Ensure that the global security field has rules defined
(CKV_OPENAPI_4)
[HIGH] 1-89: Ensure that security operations is not empty.
(CKV_OPENAPI_5)
🔇 Additional comments (8)
lambda/index.js (4)
10-10: LGTM! Well-organized handler imports and typo fix.
The changes demonstrate good code organization:
- Fixed the typo in the environment variable setter name
- Added new handlers with clear separation of concerns
- Maintained modular structure with handlers in separate files
Also applies to: 24-28, 30-38
222-225: LGTM! Well-organized interceptor chain
The interceptors are arranged in a logical order:
- Request logging
- Localization setup
- Environment configuration
- Session management
43-47:
Fix syntax error in canHandle method
The extra parenthesis breaks the logical OR condition in the canHandle method.
Apply this fix:
return (
Alexa.getRequestType(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "LaunchRequest" ||
!handlerInput.requestEnvelope.request.task ||
- )(
Alexa.getRequestType(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "IntentRequest" &&
Alexa.getIntentName(handlerInput.requestEnvelope) === "LaunchIntent"
);Likely invalid or redundant comment.
196-198: Review handler order for correct request routing
The audio-related handlers are placed at the start of the request handlers chain. In Alexa skills, the order matters as handlers are evaluated sequentially. Consider if these handlers should have such high precedence or if they should be moved lower in the chain to avoid intercepting requests meant for other handlers.
skill-package/routines/triggers/PlayAdhaan/en-CA.json (1)
1-40: Same issues as en-US configuration
This file has identical structure and content as the en-US configuration.
Please apply the same fixes recommended for the en-US configuration regarding:
- Icon URL hosting
- Display property duplication
lambda/handlers/intentHandler.js (1)
153-153: Verify character display handling across all locales
Multiple handlers now use checkForCharacterDisplay, but its behavior needs to be verified across different locales.
Also applies to: 179-179, 234-234, 287-287
✅ Verification successful
Let me gather more information about the implementation of checkForCharacterDisplay to understand its behavior.
Let me check the APL document and any locale-specific handling in the helper functions.
Let me check the interceptors and translation handler to understand how localization is handled.
Based on the gathered information, I can now provide the final response:
Character display handling is properly implemented across locales
The implementation is robust with multiple safeguards:
- Text translation is handled via Google Translate API with fallback to original text
- Locale detection and language-specific handling through i18next
- Character display is managed through APLT interface with proper fallbacks
- The system includes automatic language detection and appropriate text conversion
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check for character display handling across locales
# Test: Search for all checkForCharacterDisplay calls and their corresponding locale strings
# Find all locale string files
echo "Checking locale files for character display strings..."
fd -e js -p "lambda/prompts" --exec cat {} \; | rg "characterDisplay|display.*character"
# Find all checkForCharacterDisplay usages
echo "Checking usage of checkForCharacterDisplay..."
rg "checkForCharacterDisplay" --type js
Length of output: 1144
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Get the implementation of checkForCharacterDisplay
ast-grep --pattern 'function checkForCharacterDisplay($_) {
$$$
}'
# Check if there are any locale-specific character handling
rg -B2 -A5 "characterDisplay|display.*character" lambda/helperFunctions.js
Length of output: 564
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check the APL document content
cat lambda/aplDocuments/characterDisplayApl.json
# Look for any locale or language handling in helperFunctions
rg -B3 -A3 "locale|language|translate" lambda/helperFunctions.js
# Check for any locale-specific imports or configurations
rg -l "i18n|locale|language" lambda/
Length of output: 2410
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check interceptors for locale handling
cat lambda/interceptors.js
# Check translation handler implementation
cat lambda/handlers/googleTranslateHandler.js
# Look for actual usage of checkForCharacterDisplay function
rg -B5 -A5 "function checkForCharacterDisplay" lambda/helperFunctions.js
Length of output: 8529
skill-package/skill.json (2)
503-547: LGTM: Privacy and compliance settings are well configured
The privacy and compliance section is properly configured with:
- No purchases allowed
- No ads
- Not child-directed
- No personal info usage
- Terms and privacy URLs for all locales
495-502: Verify minimum permission scope
The skill requests full address and geolocation permissions. Verify if both are necessary.
✅ Verification successful
Both address and geolocation permissions are necessary
The code analysis shows both permissions are actively used and serve different purposes:
-
Address permission (
alexa::devices:all:address:full:read):- Used in
getDeviceAddressServiceClient()to fetch user's full address - Address data is converted to coordinates via Google Geocoding API
- Essential for finding nearby mosques when geolocation is unavailable
- Used in
-
Geolocation permission (
alexa::devices:all:geolocation:read):- Provides direct access to device location
- Serves as a primary method for location-based features
- Address serves as a fallback mechanism
The implementation follows best practices by having both options available, ensuring the skill can function even if one method fails.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check usage of address and geolocation permissions
# Test: Search for address and geolocation API usage
echo "Checking address API usage..."
rg "getDeviceAddress|address" --type js
echo "Checking geolocation API usage..."
rg "getDeviceLocation|geolocation" --type js
Length of output: 3386
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
♻️ Duplicate comments (1)
skill-package/tasks/PlayAdhaan.1.json (1)
1-7:⚠️ Potential issueAdd security definitions for API protection
The API specification lacks security definitions, which is crucial for protecting the endpoints. This was previously flagged and needs to be addressed.
Add security configuration:
{ "openapi": "3.0.0", + "security": [ + { + "alexaSkill": [] + } + ], "info": { "title": "Play Adhaan", "version": "1", "x-amzn-alexa-access-scope": "public", + "components": { + "securitySchemes": { + "alexaSkill": { + "type": "apiKey", + "name": "Authorization", + "in": "header" + } + } + } }🧰 Tools
🪛 checkov (3.2.334)
[HIGH] 1-94: Ensure that the global security field has rules defined
(CKV_OPENAPI_4)
[HIGH] 1-94: Ensure that security operations is not empty.
(CKV_OPENAPI_5)
🧹 Nitpick comments (5)
lambda/handlers/apiHandler.js (1)
72-89: Consider returning additional hadith metadataThe implementation looks good and follows consistent patterns. However, consider returning additional metadata (if available in the response) such as narrator, chapter, or authenticity grade to enhance the user experience.
- return response.data.text; + return { + text: response.data.text, + narrator: response.data.narrator, + chapter: response.data.chapter, + grade: response.data.grade + };lambda/index.js (1)
195-213: Consider grouping related handlers togetherWhile the handler chain organization is functional, consider grouping related handlers together for better maintainability:
- Core handlers (Launch, Help, etc.)
- Audio-related handlers
- Prayer-related handlers
- Touch event handlers
- System handlers (Fallback, SessionEnded, etc.)
.addRequestHandlers( LaunchRequestHandler, HelpIntentHandler, + // Audio handlers group AudioPlayerEventHandler, PlaybackCommandHandler, AudioIntentHandler, + // Prayer & Mosque handlers group MosqueInfoIntentHandler, AllIqamaTimeIntentHandler, NextPrayerTimeIntentHandler, NextIqamaTimeIntentHandler, AllPrayerTimeIntentHandler, PlayAdhanIntentHandler, SelectMosqueIntentStartedHandler, SelectMosqueIntentAfterSelectingMosqueHandler, FavoriteAdhaanReciterStartedHandler, FavoriteAdhaanReciterIntentHandler, + // Additional features group HadithIntentHandler, RoutinesTriggerHandler, DeleteDataIntentHandler, + // Touch handlers group MosqueListTouchEventHandler, AdhaanRecitationTouchEventHandler, + // System handlers group SkillEventHandler, CancelAndStopIntentHandler, FallbackIntentHandler, SessionEndedRequestHandler, IntentReflectorHandler )skill-package/tasks/PlayAdhaan.1.json (3)
29-29: Fix inconsistent spacing in French locale titleThere's an extra space at the end of the title in the fr-FR locale.
- "title": "Play Adhaan ", + "title": "Play Adhaan",
40-43: Consider adding rate limiting configurationThe API endpoint lacks rate limiting configuration, which is important to prevent abuse.
Consider adding rate limiting headers and documentation:
"/PlayAdhaan": { "summary": "Play Adhaan", "description": "Alexa will play Adhaan", + "x-amazon-apigateway-integration": { + "x-amazon-apigateway-rate-limiting": { + "burstLimit": 10, + "rateLimit": 5 + } + },
84-92: Add validation constraints to the response schemaThe
SuccessfulResponseschema lacks validation constraints for theendTimeproperty."SuccessfulResponse": { "type": "object", + "required": ["endTime"], "properties": { "endTime": { "type": "string", - "format": "date-time" + "format": "date-time", + "description": "The time when the Adhaan playback will end", + "example": "2024-12-25T12:00:00Z" } } }
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (3)
lambda/handlers/apiHandler.js(2 hunks)lambda/index.js(3 hunks)skill-package/tasks/PlayAdhaan.1.json(1 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🪛 checkov (3.2.334)
skill-package/tasks/PlayAdhaan.1.json
[HIGH] 1-94: Ensure that the global security field has rules defined
(CKV_OPENAPI_4)
[HIGH] 1-94: Ensure that security operations is not empty.
(CKV_OPENAPI_5)
🔇 Additional comments (3)
lambda/handlers/apiHandler.js (1)
73-73: Verify API version consistency
The function uses API version "2.0" while other endpoints use "3.0". Ensure this is intentional and documented.
✅ Verification successful
Based on the search results, I can now generate the final response:
API version usage is consistent with the codebase design
The codebase shows that version "2.0" is specifically used for hadith-related endpoints, while "3.0" is the default version in the getConfig function. This appears to be intentional as the version is explicitly set for these specific endpoints rather than relying on the default.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check API version usage across the codebase
rg -B 2 -A 2 'getConfig.*"[23]\.0"'
Length of output: 1130
lambda/index.js (2)
43-47: LGTM! Fixed canHandle logic
The syntax error in the LaunchRequestHandler's canHandle logic has been fixed correctly.
221-224: LGTM! Well-organized interceptors
The interceptors are organized in a logical order: logging, localization, environment setup, and session management.
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
Bug Fixes
Documentation
Chores