gopass show -o shows unexpected warning

[mcnesium]

gopass still shows warnings, when passing the -o flag to gopass show:

correct and expected behavior:

gopass some/thing
⚠ some/thing is a secret and a folder. Use 'gopass show some/thing' to display the secret and 'gopass list some/thing' to show the content of the folder
Secret: some/thing

612709qBg2rCkQckzy9pxwRNz80tglG

imho unnecessary but i guess acceptable behavior:

gopass show some/thing
⚠ some/thing is a secret and a folder. Use 'gopass show some/thing' to display the secret and 'gopass list some/thing' to show the content of the folder
Secret: some/thing

612709qBg2rCkQckzy9pxwRNz80tglG

note: the warning does not appear when using gopass list. intended behavior?

gopass list some/thing
some/thing/
├── api_key
└── api_secret

unexpected behavior:

gopass show -o some/thing
⚠ some/thing is a secret and a folder. Use 'gopass show some/thing' to display the secret and 'gopass list some/thing' to show the content of the folder
612709qBg2rCkQckzy9pxwRNz80tglG

gopass help show | grep -- -o
   --password, -o             Display only the password. Takes precedence over all other flags. (default: false)

This gopass is installed from Manjaro community repo:

gopass --version
gopass 1.12.6 (2021-05-11 15:27:04) go1.16.4 linux amd64

[roalcantara]

Same here!

Summary

What is the proper approach to store "nested secrets"?

Steps To Reproduce

Given the following environment

$ gopass --version
  gopass 1.12.8 (2021-08-28 17:36:37) go1.17 darwin amd64

$ gopass-jsonapi --version
  gopass-jsonapi version 1.11.1

And I have stored a password

$ gopass insert leaf.jp/naruto
  Enter password for leaf.jp/naruto: *****
  Confirmg password for leaf.jp/naruto: *****

And I also have stored a memorable pin into the same secret

$ gopass generate --clip --generator memorable leaf.jp/naruto/pin 6

When I show the entry I then receive the following warning

$ gopass show -n leaf.jp/naruto
  ⚠ leaf.jp/naruto is a secret and a folder. Use 'gopass show leaf.jp/naruto' to display the secret and 'gopass list leaf.jp/naruto' to show the content of the folder

  Secret: leaf.jp/naruto

And when I reveal the password then I receive the same warning

$ gopass -o leaf.jp/naruto
  ⚠ leaf.jp/naruto is a secret and a folder. Use 'gopass show leaf.jp/naruto' to display the secret and 'gopass list leaf.jp/naruto' to show the content of the folder

  dattebayo

But I can reveal the memorable pin with no issues

$ gopass -o leaf.jp/naruto/pin
  oro!!!

Also, Gopass Bridge seems to only recognize the deepest secret 😓

Environment

$ uname -a
  Darwin Rogerios-MBP 20.6.0 Darwin Kernel Version 20.6.0

$ brew install gopass
$ brew install gopass-jsonapi

Additional context

I wasn't able to find any hints on the docs so far. :(

Excellent job, btw! I wish I could build something 10% as cool as this! 🤩

[AnomalRoil]

@roalcantara The proper way to store a "pin" in an entry is to rely on key-values:

$ gopass generate --clip --generator memorable leaf.jp/naruto 20

$ gopass generate --clip --generator memorable leaf.jp/naruto pin 6

$ gopass show -f leaf.jp/naruto
Secret: leaf.jp/naruto

hollow5deliver5shoe2
pin: extra4

$ gopass show -f leaf.jp/naruto pin
Secret: leaf.jp/naruto
Key: pin

extra4

Notice the way I use a space to add a key to an entry:

gopass generate --clip --generator memorable leaf.jp/naruto pin 6

This adds a key "pin" to the entry "leaf.jp/naruto", whereas what you are doing is creating a new entry "leaf.jp/naruto/pin" in the folder "leaf.jp/naruto" while there already is an existing entry "leaf.jp/naruto" as well.
See maybe also the documentation:

• about key-values: https://github.com/gopasspw/gopass/blob/master/docs/commands/show.md#parsing-and-secrets
• about "shadowing an entry with a folder": https://github.com/gopasspw/gopass/blob/master/docs/commands/list.md#shadowing

This should works as expected in theory with the bridge and everything.

@mcnesium I can still reprodruce the issue with -o showing the warning, will look into that.

[mcnesium]

Thanks for fixing 👍