Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

[BUG]: External room thermostat sets temperature shift. #123

Closed
Richard-Kroon opened this issue Aug 11, 2023 · 8 comments
Closed

[BUG]: External room thermostat sets temperature shift. #123

Richard-Kroon opened this issue Aug 11, 2023 · 8 comments
Assignees
@edterbak
Labels
bug Something isn't working
Milestone
Stable Release (v...

Comments

@Richard-Kroon
Copy link

Richard-Kroon commented Aug 11, 2023 •
edited
Loading

Heatpump setting: Zone & sensor > sensor > Room thermostat.
When the heatpump is configured with a external room thermostat (in my case with CN2 on/off functionality)the node red flow is not working correctly. Changing the recommended water temp. seems to do nothing.

Outlet setpoint is not changing and also WAR does not follow the curve.
logging ( Function WAR: RoomThermostat found or using Compensation curve. Using internal Panasonic WAR function. NodeRed WAR function is now disabled)

node-red outlet setpoint

WAR heat shift
@Richard-Kroon Richard-Kroon added the bug Something isn't working label Aug 11, 2023
@edterbak edterbak self-assigned this Aug 11, 2023
@edterbak edterbak added this to the Stable Release (v24.00) milestone Aug 11, 2023
edterbak added a commit that referenced this issue Aug 31, 2023
@edterbak
Update README.md
1ccf855 
[2023-08-21] v23.07 Stable. Changes:
- [FIX] Scheduler - Due to grouping the scheduler did not function anymore. This should now be improved a lot. #128
- [FIX] Home dashboard did not show correct temperature behind 'Water temp'. Related to #123.
- [FIX] Detection on persistent storage should now work propperly.
edterbak added a commit that referenced this issue Aug 31, 2023
@edterbak
Add files via upload
c95aa7d 
[2023-08-21] v23.07 Stable. Changes:
- [FIX] Scheduler - Due to grouping the scheduler did not function anymore. This should now be improved a lot. #128
- [FIX] Home dashboard did not show correct temperature behind 'Water temp'. Related to #123.
- [FIX] Detection on persistent storage should now work propperly.
@edterbak
Copy link
Owner

edterbak commented Oct 16, 2023 •
edited
Loading

Hi Richard,

First of all, sorry for the late reply. I saw your issue, thought to react but I forgot again.

Can you help me fix this.
Are you using Direct operating mode or Compensation Curve?

I would like a copy of all the data in your heishamon.

Like so:

Topic Name Value Description
TOP0 Heatpump_State 1 On
TOP1 Pump_Flow 20.54 l/min
TOP2 Force_DHW_State 0 Disabled
TOP3 Quiet_Mode_Schedule 0 Disabled
TOP4 Operating_Mode_State 0 Heat
TOP5 Main_Inlet_Temp 28 °C
TOP6 Main_Outlet_Temp 30.25 °C
TOP7 Main_Target_Temp 30 °C
TOP8 Compressor_Freq 27 Hz
TOP9 DHW_Target_Temp 52 °C
TOP10 DHW_Temp 47 °C
TOP11 Operations_Hours 8256 hours
TOP12 Operations_Counter 8249 count
TOP13 Main_Schedule_State 0 Disabled
TOP14 Outside_Temp 8 °C
TOP15 Heat_Energy_Production 3200 Watt
TOP16 Heat_Energy_Consumption 600 Watt
TOP17 Powerful_Mode_Time 0 Off
TOP18 Quiet_Mode_Level 2 Level 2
TOP19 Holiday_Mode_State 0 Off
TOP20 ThreeWay_Valve_State 0 Room
TOP21 Outside_Pipe_Temp 3 °C
TOP22 DHW_Heat_Delta -5 K
TOP23 Heat_Delta 2 K
TOP24 Cool_Delta 1 K
TOP25 DHW_Holiday_Shift_Temp -15 K
TOP26 Defrosting_State 0 Disabled
TOP27 Z1_Heat_Request_Temp 2 °C
TOP28 Z1_Cool_Request_Temp 18 °C
TOP29 Z1_Heat_Curve_Target_High_Temp 30 °C
TOP30 Z1_Heat_Curve_Target_Low_Temp 26 °C
TOP31 Z1_Heat_Curve_Outside_High_Temp 14 °C
TOP32 Z1_Heat_Curve_Outside_Low_Temp -5 °C
TOP33 Room_Thermostat_Temp 24 °C
TOP34 Z2_Heat_Request_Temp 0 °C
TOP35 Z2_Cool_Request_Temp 10 °C
TOP36 Z1_Water_Temp -78 °C
TOP37 Z2_Water_Temp -78 °C
TOP38 Cool_Energy_Production 0 Watt
TOP39 Cool_Energy_Consumption 0 Watt
TOP40 DHW_Energy_Production 0 Watt
TOP41 DHW_Energy_Consumption 0 Watt
TOP42 Z1_Water_Target_Temp 30 °C
TOP43 Z2_Water_Target_Temp 42 °C
TOP44 Error No error Error
TOP45 Room_Holiday_Shift_Temp -15 K
TOP46 Buffer_Temp -78 °C
TOP47 Solar_Temp -78 °C
TOP48 Pool_Temp -78 °C
TOP49 Main_Hex_Outlet_Temp 31 °C
TOP50 Discharge_Temp 39 °C
TOP51 Inside_Pipe_Temp 30 °C
TOP52 Defrost_Temp -31 °C
TOP53 Eva_Outlet_Temp 4 °C
TOP54 Bypass_Outlet_Temp -31 °C
TOP55 Ipm_Temp 21 °C
TOP56 Z1_Temp 30 °C
TOP57 Z2_Temp -128 °C
TOP58 DHW_Heater_State 1 Free
TOP59 Room_Heater_State 1 Free
TOP60 Internal_Heater_State 0 Inactive
TOP61 External_Heater_State 0 Inactive
TOP62 Fan1_Motor_Speed 390 r/min
TOP63 Fan2_Motor_Speed 0 r/min
TOP64 High_Pressure 19.4 Kgf/cm2
TOP65 Pump_Speed 3500 r/min
TOP66 Low_Pressure 0 Kgf/cm2
TOP67 Compressor_Current 2.8 Ampere
TOP68 Force_Heater_State 0 Inactive
TOP69 Sterilization_State 0 Inactive
TOP70 Sterilization_Temp 62 °C
TOP71 Sterilization_Max_Time 60 Minutes
TOP72 Z1_Cool_Curve_Target_High_Temp 18 °C
TOP73 Z1_Cool_Curve_Target_Low_Temp 10 °C
TOP74 Z1_Cool_Curve_Outside_High_Temp 15 °C
TOP75 Z1_Cool_Curve_Outside_Low_Temp 20 °C
TOP76 Heating_Mode 0 Comp. Curve
TOP77 Heating_Off_Outdoor_Temp 35 °C
TOP78 Heater_On_Outdoor_Temp 0 °C
TOP79 Heat_To_Cool_Temp 25 °C
TOP80 Cool_To_Heat_Temp 20 °C
TOP81 Cooling_Mode 1 Direct
TOP82 Z2_Heat_Curve_Target_High_Temp 55 °C
TOP83 Z2_Heat_Curve_Target_Low_Temp 35 °C
TOP84 Z2_Heat_Curve_Outside_High_Temp 15 °C
TOP85 Z2_Heat_Curve_Outside_Low_Temp -5 °C
TOP86 Z2_Cool_Curve_Target_High_Temp 10 °C
TOP87 Z2_Cool_Curve_Target_Low_Temp 10 °C
TOP88 Z2_Cool_Curve_Outside_High_Temp 30 °C
TOP89 Z2_Cool_Curve_Outside_Low_Temp 20 °C
TOP90 Room_Heater_Operations_Hours 66 hours
TOP91 DHW_Heater_Operations_Hours 151 hours
TOP92 Heat_Pump_Model 20 WH-MDC07J3E5
TOP93 Pump_Duty 140 Duty
TOP94 Zones_State 0 Zone1 active
TOP95 Max_Pump_Duty 140 Duty
TOP96 Heater_Delay_Time 30 Minutes
TOP97 Heater_Start_Delta -5 K
TOP98 Heater_Stop_Delta 0 K
TOP99 Buffer_Installed 0 Disabled
TOP100 DHW_Installed 1 Enabled
TOP101 Solar_Mode 0 Disabled
TOP102 Solar_On_Delta 10 K
TOP103 Solar_Off_Delta 5 K
TOP104 Solar_Frost_Protection 5 °C
TOP105 Solar_High_Limit 80 °C
TOP106 Pump_Flowrate_Mode 0 DeltaT
TOP107 Liquid_Type 0 Water
TOP108 Alt_External_Sensor 0 Disabled
TOP109 Anti_Freeze_Mode 1 Enabled
TOP110 Optional_PCB 0 Disabled
TOP111 Z1_Sensor_Settings 0 Water Temperature
TOP112 Z2_Sensor_Settings 0 Water Temperature
TOP113 Buffer_Tank_Delta 5 K
TOP114 External_Pad_Heater 0 Disabled

@Richard-Kroon
Copy link
Author

Hi edterbak,

When the heatpump is configured with a external room thermostat I can choose both, direct mode or Compensation Curve.
I use Direct mode, but heatshifting is not possible when using the thermostat setting.

all the data in heishamon with the Heatpump setting: Zone & sensor > sensor > Room thermostat.

TOP0 Heatpump_State 1 On
TOP1 Pump_Flow 0.13 l/min
TOP2 Force_DHW_State 0 Disabled
TOP3 Quiet_Mode_Schedule 0 Disabled
TOP4 Operating_Mode_State 3 DHW
TOP5 Main_Inlet_Temp 24.75 °C
TOP6 Main_Outlet_Temp 24.75 °C
TOP7 Main_Target_Temp 29 °C
TOP8 Compressor_Freq 0 Hz
TOP9 DHW_Target_Temp 45 °C
TOP10 DHW_Temp 55 °C
TOP11 Operations_Hours 4809 hours
TOP12 Operations_Counter 5483 count
TOP13 Main_Schedule_State 0 Disabled
TOP14 Outside_Temp 13 °C
TOP15 Heat_Energy_Production 0 Watt
TOP16 Heat_Energy_Consumption 0 Watt
TOP17 Powerful_Mode_Time 0 Off
TOP18 Quiet_Mode_Level 0 Off
TOP19 Holiday_Mode_State 0 Off
TOP20 ThreeWay_Valve_State 0 Room
TOP21 Outside_Pipe_Temp 12 °C
TOP22 DHW_Heat_Delta -10 K
TOP23 Heat_Delta 4 K
TOP24 Cool_Delta 5 K
TOP25 DHW_Holiday_Shift_Temp -15 K
TOP26 Defrosting_State 0 Disabled
TOP27 Z1_Heat_Request_Temp 0 °C
TOP28 Z1_Cool_Request_Temp 0 °C
TOP29 Z1_Heat_Curve_Target_High_Temp 29 °C
TOP30 Z1_Heat_Curve_Target_Low_Temp 35 °C
TOP31 Z1_Heat_Curve_Outside_High_Temp 15 °C
TOP32 Z1_Heat_Curve_Outside_Low_Temp -5 °C
TOP33 Room_Thermostat_Temp 24 °C
TOP34 Z2_Heat_Request_Temp 35 °C
TOP35 Z2_Cool_Request_Temp 0 °C
TOP36 Z1_Water_Temp -78 °C
TOP37 Z2_Water_Temp -78 °C
TOP38 Cool_Energy_Production 0 Watt
TOP39 Cool_Energy_Consumption 0 Watt
TOP40 DHW_Energy_Production 0 Watt
TOP41 DHW_Energy_Consumption 0 Watt
TOP42 Z1_Water_Target_Temp 29 °C
TOP43 Z2_Water_Target_Temp 35 °C
TOP44 Error No error Error
TOP45 Room_Holiday_Shift_Temp -15 K
TOP46 Buffer_Temp -78 °C
TOP47 Solar_Temp -78 °C
TOP48 Pool_Temp -78 °C
TOP49 Main_Hex_Outlet_Temp 25 °C
TOP50 Discharge_Temp 20 °C
TOP51 Inside_Pipe_Temp 24 °C
TOP52 Defrost_Temp 0 °C
TOP53 Eva_Outlet_Temp 14 °C
TOP54 Bypass_Outlet_Temp 0 °C
TOP55 Ipm_Temp 16 °C
TOP56 Z1_Temp 24 °C
TOP57 Z2_Temp -128 °C
TOP58 DHW_Heater_State 1 Free
TOP59 Room_Heater_State 1 Free
TOP60 Internal_Heater_State 0 Inactive
TOP61 External_Heater_State 0 Inactive
TOP62 Fan1_Motor_Speed 0 r/min
TOP63 Fan2_Motor_Speed 0 r/min
TOP64 High_Pressure 11.4 Kgf/cm2
TOP65 Pump_Speed 0 r/min
TOP66 Low_Pressure 0 Kgf/cm2
TOP67 Compressor_Current 0.0 Ampere
TOP68 Force_Heater_State 0 Inactive
TOP69 Sterilization_State 0 Inactive
TOP70 Sterilization_Temp 62 °C
TOP71 Sterilization_Max_Time 5 Minutes
TOP72 Z1_Cool_Curve_Target_High_Temp 15 °C
TOP73 Z1_Cool_Curve_Target_Low_Temp 10 °C
TOP74 Z1_Cool_Curve_Outside_High_Temp 30 °C
TOP75 Z1_Cool_Curve_Outside_Low_Temp 20 °C
TOP76 Heating_Mode 1 Direct
TOP77 Heating_Off_Outdoor_Temp 20 °C
TOP78 Heater_On_Outdoor_Temp -5 °C
TOP79 Heat_To_Cool_Temp 15 °C
TOP80 Cool_To_Heat_Temp 10 °C
TOP81 Cooling_Mode 0 Comp. Curve
TOP82 Z2_Heat_Curve_Target_High_Temp 35 °C
TOP83 Z2_Heat_Curve_Target_Low_Temp 35 °C
TOP84 Z2_Heat_Curve_Outside_High_Temp 15 °C
TOP85 Z2_Heat_Curve_Outside_Low_Temp -5 °C
TOP86 Z2_Cool_Curve_Target_High_Temp 15 °C
TOP87 Z2_Cool_Curve_Target_Low_Temp 10 °C
TOP88 Z2_Cool_Curve_Outside_High_Temp 30 °C
TOP89 Z2_Cool_Curve_Outside_Low_Temp 20 °C
TOP90 Room_Heater_Operations_Hours 105 hours
TOP91 DHW_Heater_Operations_Hours 288 hours
TOP92 Heat_Pump_Model 18 IDU: WH-SDC0709J3E5, ODU: WH-UD07JE5
TOP93 Pump_Duty 0 Duty
TOP94 Zones_State 0 Zone1 active
TOP95 Max_Pump_Duty 197 Duty
TOP96 Heater_Delay_Time 30 Minutes
TOP97 Heater_Start_Delta -4 K
TOP98 Heater_Stop_Delta -2 K
TOP99 Buffer_Installed 0 Disabled
TOP100 DHW_Installed 1 Enabled
TOP101 Solar_Mode 0 Disabled
TOP102 Solar_On_Delta 10 K
TOP103 Solar_Off_Delta 5 K
TOP104 Solar_Frost_Protection 5 °C
TOP105 Solar_High_Limit 80 °C
TOP106 Pump_Flowrate_Mode 0 DeltaT
TOP107 Liquid_Type 0 Water
TOP108 Alt_External_Sensor 0 Disabled
TOP109 Anti_Freeze_Mode 1 Enabled
TOP110 Optional_PCB 0 Disabled
TOP111 Z1_Sensor_Settings 0 External Thermostat
TOP112 Z2_Sensor_Settings 0 Water Temperature
TOP113 Buffer_Tank_Delta 5 K
TOP114 External_Pad_Heater 0 Disabled

@edterbak
Copy link
Owner

edterbak commented Oct 21, 2023 •
edited
Loading

TOP111 Z1_Sensor_Settings 0 External Thermostat

That does not look right... This confuses me.
Can you please do the change of the setting, and wait for 2 minutes to make sure all values come in heishamon, then do the copy past.?

@edterbak
Copy link
Owner

I uploaded v23.10 beta9. It should be improving on this problem ... a lot.
Hope you can confirm.

@edterbak
Copy link
Owner

Hi @Richard-Kroon

Can you retest the latest beta v32, to see if this latest version solves the reported issues?

@Richard-Kroon
Copy link
Author

Hi @edterbak

I'm using beta v31 for a while now, basic functionality works great and i'm very happy with it.
Will start testing v32 staring today and let you know if there are any issues.

@edterbak
Copy link
Owner

edterbak commented Dec 4, 2023

I haver released v24.00 stable

It contains the same logic as in beta 32. So if you do not have any issues anymore with this beta 32 version, can you please close this issue?

@edterbak
Copy link
Owner

edterbak commented Jan 8, 2024

@Richard-Kroon
It would be nice if you can confirm this issue to be fixed 😄

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees

@edterbak edterbak

Labels
bug Something isn't working
Projects
None yet
Milestone
Stable Release (v24.00)
Development

No branches or pull requests
2 participants
@edterbak @Richard-Kroon