TS0043 different states for same device

[arteck]

we need a standard state for ts0043 with or without a other manufacturerName

[Koenkk]

Why is the current one not good? We should prevent to change this as it will lead to a breaking change.

[arteck]

we have a problem in iobroker with..

[Koenkk]

Can you describe more of this problem?

[kirovilya]

TS0043 model for devices with three buttons.
but with this model several manufacturers make devices.
and it is surprising that in one case the {action: 1_click} event arrives for a device with the TS0043 model, and if you take the same device from another manufacturer - you get {action: right_click}.
I believe that here it is necessary either to unify events for one device model, or to divide them into different device models.
another problem concerns iobroker.zigbee - we describe events for a device with separate entities, so we need to know what value will come to action for a specific device model. in the case of TS0043, we have a problem - the values ​​may be different.

I believe that it is better to bring the action value to one type, and not to divide by manufacturer.

[Koenkk]

Thanks I understand your point now. In that case I propose to get rid of the whole if/else button mapping and always set buttonMapping to const buttonMapping = {1: '1', 2: '2', 3: '3', 4: '4'};

[kirovilya]

I agree, we can remove the comparison with ManufacturerName

[arteck]

i make a new one

#1652