[Bug] Yarn 2 does not run prepare script for git dependencies

[trusktr]

This issue is basically the same as described at yarnpkg/yarn#7910, but for Yarn 2.

[arcanis]

This is expected, cf:
https://yarnpkg.com/advanced/lifecycle-scripts

Tldr: use prepack rather than prepare.

[trusktr]

@arcanis Ah, interesting. Does Yarn have plans to be compatible with the same scripts as npm?

I hadn't known about prepack running on git installs (maybe a newer npm feature after prepare was used for git installs?), but it does seem like the better option.

[trusktr]

(updated my last comment, accidentally wrote "Lerna" instead of "Yarn")

[arcanis]

Does Yarn have plans to be compatible with the same scripts as npm?

From the page I linked:

Note that we don't support every single lifecycle script originally present in npm. This is a deliberate decision based on the observation that too many lifecycle scripts make it difficult to know which one to use in which circumstances, leading to confusion and mistakes. We are open to add the missing ones on a case-by-case basis if compelling use cases are provided.

As for

I hadn't known about prepack running on git installs (maybe a newer npm feature after prepare was used for git installs?), but it does seem like the better option.

No, prepack is an fairly old script. The difference between it and prepare was very subtle (prepare runs on installs too), hence why people really didn't know which one to use.

[cinderblock]

Why doesn't prepack run on "git install"? "git install" as in adding a git repository as a package.json dependency.

One major feature, imho, of how Npm runs prepare scripts is being able to directly install a git repository as a package.json dependency. Since a git repository should not contain compiled sources, a "build" step is often necessary to generate usable sources. Having that "build" step run as a prepare script means it's trivial to add a git "package" as a dependency and it will work just like it had been installed via npmjs.com.

If instead the prepack hook is used, it will correctly build before packing, but won't build after installing from git.

What is the intended way for Yarn to support adding/installing from (git) sources and automatically building after?

[arcanis]

Why doesn't prepack run on "git install"? "git install" as in adding a git repository as a package.json dependency.

It does.

[cinderblock]

My mistake. I was accidentally testing with Yarn 1.

However, my point remains, how is a package maintainer expected to make their git package work for both Yarn and Npm?

Lifecycle scripts run on "git install".

Yarn 2.4.2	Npm v7.15.1	Match
postinstall	postinstall	✔️
prepack		❌
	prepare	❌
	prepublish	❌

A postinstall script is the only one they both run. So that? Or the same script in prepack and prepare? Doesn't that make Npm potentially double up on scripts?

Edit: Did some more tests: https://github.com/cinderblock/test-npm-yarn-lifecycle-scripts

[GNUGradyn]

even prepack doesnt seem to work in yarn 3 lol