some redirected/renamed node URLs broken

[jywarren]

What happened just before the problem occurred

I wanted to go to:

https://publiclab.org/notes/liz/08-03-2011/infrared-balloon-image-reveals-gowanus-plume

But I found that the post only exists now at:

https://publiclab.org/notes/liz/8-3-2011/ir-reveals-gowanus-plume

This page is also possibly broken: https://publiclab.org/notes/hunter/7-19-2012/irvs-timelapse

We used to use redirect records to allow multiple URLs to point to (redirect to) the same node. What I believe is happening is that the redirect records are not working anymore? Also see removal of the legacy DrupalUrlRedirect system in #73 -- specifically this comment: #73 (comment)

This could also relate to more recent wiki path issues in #697.

---

Update: according to the comment above, some nodes in the pre-friendly_id db should be findable with: DrupalNode.find_all_by_path 'DUPLICATE' and some marked as redirects with their type as redirect|<nid>. We should scan the old database for these and fix any -- and confirm they include the broken post above.

[jywarren]

DrupalNode.where(path: 'DUPLICATE', status: 1) returns nothing.

[jywarren]

However this returns 100 records:

redirects = DrupalNode.where('type LIKE (?)', 'redirect|%').limit(100)

so... there are a lot of them. 223, to be exact:

redirect|163,redirect|220,redirect|329,redirect|329,redirect|334,redirect|220,redirect|338,redirect|338,redirect|319,redirect|339,redirect|350,redirect|348,redirect|348,redirect|2,redirect|382,redirect|79,redirect|72,redirect|72,redirect|300,redirect|425,redirect|424,redirect|441,redirect|447,redirect|450,redirect|450,redirect|457,redirect|420,redirect|328,redirect|483,redirect|482,redirect|481,redirect|496,redirect|502,redirect|90,redirect|503,redirect|407,redirect|488,redirect|444,redirect|540,redirect|514,redirect|541,redirect|538,redirect|568,redirect|588,redirect|605,redirect|606,redirect|607,redirect|620,redirect|626,redirect|507,redirect|539,redirect|71,redirect|657,redirect|22,redirect|71,redirect|688,redirect|18,redirect|718,redirect|726,redirect|740,redirect|740,redirect|740,redirect|789,redirect|792,redirect|794,redirect|787,redirect|787,redirect|788,redirect|813,redirect|828,redirect|829,redirect|648,redirect|826,redirect|826,redirect|273,redirect|834,redirect|856,redirect|860,redirect|861,redirect|827,redirect|539,redirect|900,redirect|828,redirect|918,redirect|924,redirect|1458,redirect|1459,redirect|1460,redirect|1461,redirect|1462,redirect|1463,redirect|1464,redirect|1490,redirect|539,redirect|1584,redirect|1587,redirect|1592,redirect|508,redirect|1623,redirect|1748,redirect|1781,redirect|623,redirect|1848,redirect|1827,redirect|1877,redirect|3,redirect|1909,redirect|539,redirect|1911,redirect|1950,redirect|1989,redirect|2008,redirect|2009,redirect|2011,redirect|762,redirect|2120,redirect|539,redirect|2287,redirect|2220,redirect|2312,redirect|2338,redirect|2396,redirect|2422,redirect|2423,redirect|2424,redirect|539,redirect|2618,redirect|2626,redirect|539,redirect|539,redirect|539,redirect|2715,redirect|2257,redirect|2930,redirect|2962,redirect|2866,redirect|3004,redirect|3124,redirect|2626,redirect|1748,redirect|1490,redirect|3181,redirect|3231,redirect|90,redirect|69,redirect|407,redirect|3465,redirect|3547,redirect|220,redirect|245,redirect|1830,redirect|1830,redirect|1831,redirect|1909,redirect|3739,redirect|3766,redirect|3837,redirect|3909,redirect|4127,redirect|4369,redirect|616,redirect|4691,redirect|617,redirect|4835,redirect|4835,redirect|4835,redirect|4859,redirect|4865,redirect|4998,redirect|3768,redirect|5182,redirect|5215,redirect|5215,redirect|5215,redirect|3439,redirect|3680,redirect|3109,redirect|178,redirect|178,redirect|5425,redirect|5530,redirect|5663,redirect|5850,redirect|5978,redirect|5850,redirect|5987,redirect|6038,redirect|6038,redirect|6083,redirect|6108,redirect|6139,redirect|6175,redirect|6233,redirect|6287,redirect|5719,redirect|5719,redirect|6349,redirect|6379,redirect|6382,redirect|6425,redirect|5850,redirect|5850,redirect|6493,redirect|6525,redirect|6717,redirect|5609,redirect|657,redirect|785,redirect|6718,redirect|6956,redirect|3718,redirect|7193,redirect|7294,redirect|7341,redirect|7142,redirect|7266,redirect|7414,redirect|539,redirect|7903,redirect|8054,redirect|1789,redirect|1805,redirect|71

I put them here: https://publiclab.org/redirects.txt

[jywarren]

They indeed include: "REDIRECT-notes/liz/8-3-2011/infrared-balloon-image-reveals-gowanus-plume-0.9933278192862228" but nothing by hunter (the second broken link).

[jywarren]

I wonder if there's an issue with legacy users, since https://publiclab.org/profile/hunter also doesn't load. Maybe recent changes haven't accounted for unmigrated users. Maybe we should just auto-migrate all users who have content or comments.

[jywarren]

We can run u.migrate unless u.using_new_site? for each unmigrated user (commenters and authors). All commenters/authors (migrated and not) listed here: https://gist.github.com/jywarren/9c2043a4b8f4c568f6925905fa562487

[jywarren]

Doing that for Hunter fixed https://publiclab.org/notes/hunter/7-19-2012/irvs-timelapse. Great.

[jywarren]

this is now done for all the prior listed uids.

[jywarren]

Also, in #808 resolved #807, so that's probably not related to this.

[jywarren]

Added a test for the redirection -- and noticed that many redirect records have a path field of nil. Looking in legacy db to recover these. Related to friendly_id migration.

[jywarren]

Redirects with no path: [10715, 10716, 10717, 10718, 10719, 10720, 10721, 10724, 10725, 10726, 10727, 10729, 10731, 10734, 10735, 10738, 10740, 10741, 10743, 10744, 10745, 10747, 10748, 10749, 10750, 10751, 10752, 10753, 10754, 10755, 10756, 10757, 10759, 10760, 10761, 10762, 10764, 10766, 10767, 10769, 10770, 10771, 10772, 10773, 10774, 10775, 10776, 10777, 10778, 10779, 10780, 10781, 10782, 10784, 10787, 10789, 10790, 10791, 10793, 10794, 10795, 10796, 10797, 10800, 10801, 10802, 10803, 10804, 10805, 10806, 10807, 10808, 10809, 10810, 10811, 10814, 10815, 10816, 10817, 10818, 10819, 10820, 10821, 10822, 10823, 10824, 10825, 10826, 10827, 10828, 10829, 10830, 10831, 10832, 10833, 10834, 10835, 10836, 10837, 10838, 10839, 10840, 10841, 10842, 10843, 10844, 10845, 10846, 10847, 10848, 10849, 10850, 10851, 10852, 10853, 10854, 10855, 10856, 10857, 10860, 10861, 10862, 10863, 10864, 10865, 10866, 10867, 10868, 10869, 10870, 10872, 10873, 10878, 10879, 10880, 10881, 10882, 10883, 10885, 10886, 10887, 10889, 10890, 10891, 10892, 10894, 10895, 10896, 10897, 10898, 10899, 10900, 10902, 10903, 10904, 10905, 10906, 10907, 10908, 10909, 10911, 10912, 10913, 10914, 10915, 10917, 10918, 10919, 10920, 10921, 10923, 10924, 10925, 10926, 10927, 10928, 10929, 10930, 10931, 10932, 10933, 10934, 10935, 10936, 10937]

[jywarren]

OK -- migrated. Now:

https://publiclab.org/notes/liz/8-3-2011/infrared-balloon-image-reveals-gowanus-plume leads to

https://publiclab.org/notes/liz/8-3-2011/ir-reveals-gowanus-plume

https://publiclab.org/notes/warren/2-14-2012/ultraviolet-spectroscopy-test-350nm leads to

https://publiclab.org/notes/warren/2-14-2012/ultraviolet-spectroscopy-testing

This works and redirection is tested now here: #809