Mismatch between images and annotations in Cat-16

[yangyu12]

Hi,
I have found that in Cat-16 some annotations do not match the images. Examples are as follows

Index	Provided in Google drive	Generated from StyleGAN	Annotation	shown in supplementary material
image_23
image_26

Clearly, neither the images provided in Google drive nor the images generated from StyleGAN could match the annotations, but only the images shown in the supplementary material can match the annotations. I think this mismatch is quite obvious as an additional leg is annotated in image_23 while one leg is missing in annotations of image_26. I tend to believe that the released images and latents are wrongly taken. Is it possible to fix this issue?

[arieling]

Hi, Thank you for pointing this out. There is a discrepancy caused by the noise channel and we are looking into it.
At the same time, please ignore those two annotations.

[yangyu12]

Hi, I do not think it is caused by the noise channel. Look at the first two columns which show that the images provided in Google drive can be recovered with StyleGAN given the provided latents. Moreover, Car and Face do not have this issue.