Restrict sharing with users within the group (check field in the administration settings)

[ghost]

Steps to reproduce

1. User A in Group A / User B in Group B
2. Disable the checkbox Restrict sharing with users within the group in the admin settings
3. look in Talk at the user list

Expected behaviour

Tell us what should happen
Users from different groups should be displayed.

Actual behaviour

Tell us what happens instead
Only the users of their own group are displayed.

Talk app

Talk app version: (see apps admin page: /index.php/settings/apps)
15.0.4

Server configuration

Nextcloud AIO -stable

[nickvergessen]

Which user list? Can you add a screenshot?

[ghost]

Which user list? Can you add a screenshot?

Regardless of whether it is via the search or when creating a group, the users are not visible, as if the users in group A or the users in group B were alone on the instance.

[nickvergessen]

Can you please show a screenshot of the sharing settings?
This all works as expected here.

[ghost]

Can you please show a screenshot of the sharing settings?
This all works as expected here.

[ghost]

could you reproduce the problem? And is there more information about it?

[nickvergessen]

These are the default settings and I can see other users pretty fine.

So that brings me back to:

Which user list? Can you add a screenshot?

Without a screenshot to know where you think something is wrong, it's very hard for us to follow.

[ghost]

I don't know how to show this in a screenshot. The point is as follows: I have two groups and the users cannot see the people from other groups in their list where otherwise the other contacts with the users from the same group are also displayed (no matter in which dialog whether when creating a group, with the search or anything else) I have the problem only in Talk.

[nickvergessen]

I'm totally unsure which list and search you are talking about.
But note that chats are not automatically created with the other users, etc. So you first need to start a chat with them before they appear in the left sidebar, you might have to search then name for them to pop up in the right sidebar or when creating a new conversation.
For anything else you need to make a screenshot so we know what search or input or whatever you are talking about.

[ghost]

you might have to search then name for them to pop up in the right sidebar

This exactly is the problem: When searching for the name of another user to create a new conversation, the user you look for does not appear.

[nickvergessen]

I can not reproduce:

Description	Screenshot
Sharing settings
User "Num-Eric User" and "Bennet" don't share a group
Bennet can see Eric when searching left
In creating group conversation preload
In creating group conversation with search
In right sidebar to add a user

Is there an error logged in the console maybe? Or in the nextcloud.log of the server, or anything?

[ghost]

Very interesting... I set up an instance for testing and everything works there as you describe it. However, I have two other instances running (using Nextcloud AIO) and the problem occurs with both. Maybe it's the version of Nextcloud? I tested it with Nextcloud 26 and everything works as it should. Unfortunately, it doesn't work with my Nextcloud AIO instances.

[nickvergessen]

You might want to ask for help with the AIO then, but in Talk there is nothing to do, so I would close this issue here.
The related code is the same since many releases, so I don't think there is a problem with major versions

[pabloeisenhut]

Can I help to solve this? I have exactly this problem.