Why do we need @material/core ?

[gothraven]

I just installed notistack in a CRA and when i did yarn start I have got this error

Failed to compile.

./node_modules/notistack/dist/notistack.esm.js
Module not found: Can't resolve '@material-ui/core/ClickAwayListener' in '/--path--/node_modules/notistack/dist'

And I started asking myself why do I need @material-ui ? I don't want to use it! and why the docs doesn't even mention this ?!

Expected Behavior

I expect this to work without me needing to install @material-ui

Your Environment

Tech	Version
Notistack	v1.0.2
React	v17.0.1
Browser	chrome

[iamhosseindhv]

I get your point.
There is a work in progress to remove MUI dependency: #184

• API docs mentions notistack is atm an extension of MUI Snackbar: https://iamhosseindhv.com/notistack/demos#material-props (I do agree the mention is not very explicit)
• MUI is listed as peerDependency of notistack
  

  notistack/package.json

  Lines 26 to 29 in ecee3fe

  	"peerDependencies": {
  	"react": "^16.8.0",
  	"react-dom": "^16.8.0",
  	"@material-ui/core": "^4.0.0"

Until a new version of notistack is released which is independent of MUI, you'll have to have it installed. This won't impact your bundle size significantly if you've enabled tree shaking.

[iamhosseindhv]

Although I'm interested to know how (if at all) you're customising styling of the snackbars @gothraven

[gothraven]

@iamhosseindhv I'm actually using the provider content prop to inject my own snack-bar component and I use the message param to to send whatever I want, I use nothing but the logic of showing and dismissing snack-bars

[oncet]

Such a boomer. Was really excited for trying Notistack until I got this error. I guess I'll stick to react-toastify for now.

[Yard-Daniel]

Just checked the logs and this is still a problem after 2 years and mentioned a couple of times of the past few years 😄

yarn add notistack@alpha works, but isn't documented correctly.

[iamhosseindhv]

Hey @Yard-Daniel . The alpha version is a WIP which doesn't have dependency on MUI and will be published as the stable release.