[Question] Code-Push version for both iOS and Android

[LuisRizo]

OS:

• Windows
• MacOS
• Linux

Platform:

• iOS
• Android

Output of node -v && npm -v && npm ls --prod --depth=0

v8.9.4
6.1.0
/Users/luis
└── (empty)

Config:

Sentry.config('https://...@sentry.io/...', {
....
}).install()

---

I have following issue:

My app has different CodePush releases on Android and on iOS. iOS is ahead by 12 code-push releases. So Android has a label of v2.1.10-codepush:v23 and iOS has v2.1.10-codepush:v35. My question is related to how to handle two different code-push labels for iOS and Android as I have a feeling that Sentry is not separating iOS vs Android when I upload a new source map.

In fact, it causes things like these to happen:

In the screenshot above, the last release was made using the Android Code-Push project, and the second one using iOS.

Steps to reproduce:

• Create both iOS and Android Code-Push projects
• Make a couple more deployments on one of the platforms during development
• Once the app is stable, code-pushes are done simultaneously (iOS and then Android)
• Upload the source map as explained here: https://docs.sentry.io/clients/react-native/codepush/

Actual result:

• Versions are just strings and they don't know the difference between iOS and Android.

Expected result:

• The versions are separated by a specific platform.

Imagine the following:
iOS Code-Push is version v30, and it's uploaded to Sentry, while Android has a code-push label of v29. On the next code-push patch, Android turns v30 and iOS v31. This means that if users on iOS don't immediately update the app, their code-push version is still v30 but if their app crashes, the source map will be linked to the new javascript, which is the equivalent of v31 on iOS. This would possibly make the stack-trace useless or broken.

Any thoughts? Should I just try to have iOS and Android on the same version number to prevent this problem?

[HazAT]

Hey, so I think this is only an ui problem.
If you click on each release, check the url it should show the full release name.
We only show the truncated one in the UI.

Can you confirm this?
If not, please send a link to your account so I can take a look at it.

[LuisRizo]

Hello @HazAT, since both the Android app and iOS app have the same bundle ID, they have the same URL, only difference is, again, the code-push release version. Here's my Sentry Project's URL

[LuisRizo]

I also have issues getting my Code-Push source maps to get linked to their appropriate release, but that might deserve a new issue.

[HazAT]

OK, I see.
It shouldn't matter if the bundleID are the same as long as the artifacts you upload (sourcemaps) have a different name.

[LuisRizo]

According to the outputs of the code-push cli, the sourmaps are called:

• Android: ... --platform android --sourcemap-output build/CodePush/index.android.bundle.map
• iOS: ... --platform ios --sourcemap-output build/CodePush/main.jsbundle.map

If that is what you meant, then yes, I'm uploading them separately. Closing this issue as I trust your word :)