Support CommandWithArguments hint for

[tmccombs]

Please complete the following tasks

• I have searched the discussions
• I have searched the existing issues

Clap Version

3.0.5

Describe your use case

I have an argument like:

            Arg::new("exec-batch")
                .long("exec-batch")
                .short('X')
                .min_values(1)
                .allow_hyphen_values(true)
                .value_terminator(";")
                .value_name("cmd")

Ideally, I would be able to use .value_hint(ValueHint::CommandWithArguments) for this, but since it isn't a positional argument, I can't.

Describe the solution you'd like

Allow using ValueHint::CommandWithArguments for non-positional arguments, as long as:

1. It accepts multiple values
2. there is a value_terminator supplied

Alternatives, if applicable

possibly have a seperate hint type for this use case?

Additional Context

No response

[epage]

In what way are you not seeing this supported?

[tmccombs]

If I add .value_hint(ValueHint::CommandWithArguments) I get:

thread 'main' panicked at 'App fd: Argument 'exec-batch' has hint CommandWithArguments and must be positional.', /home/thayne/.cargo/registry/src/github.com-1ecc6299db9ec823/clap-3.0.5/src/build/app/debug_asserts.rs:210:13

There is a debug_assert that requires the argument to be positional if it has the CommandWithArguments hint.
This is also mentioned in the documentation:

the argument must be a positional argument and have .multiple_values(true) and App must use AppSettings::TrailingVarArg

[tmccombs]

I believe in this case the zsh completion would need to be different. Instead of using _cmdambivalent it would need to use something like:

" _command_names -e:*{}::args: _normal" where {} is replaced with the escaped value of the terminator.

That is, the first value is completed as a command name, and then every value after up to and including the value that matches the terminator are completed using _normal but using excluding the command up to the first value passed to the option.

See

clap/clap_complete/src/shells/zsh.rs

Line 392 in 453356e

ValueHint::CommandWithArguments => "_cmdambivalent",

[epage]

Sorry, I somehow had missed that part of the code when searching

I believe in this case the zsh completion would need to be different. Instead of using _cmdambivalent it would need to use something like:

" _command_names -e:*{}::args: _normal" where {} is replaced with the escaped value of the terminator.

That is, the first value is completed as a command name, and then every value after up to and including the value that matches the terminator are completed using _normal but using excluding the command up to the first value passed to the option.

See

clap/clap_complete/src/shells/zsh.rs

Line 392 in 453356e

ValueHint::CommandWithArguments => "_cmdambivalent",

Sounds like loosening CommandWithArguments won't help unless we manually implement the handling.

As an alternative, would per-value ValueHints help with this (something brought up in #2683)? The first value would be _cmdambivalent with the next being _normal. That being the last value hint, we'd then repeat it for all future value hints in that occurrence.

[tmccombs]

As an alternative, would per-value ValueHints help with this (something brought up in #2683)? The first value would be _cmdambivalent with the next being _normal. That being the last value hint, we'd then repeat it for all future value hints in that occurrence.

I'm guessing you ment _command_names - not _cmdambivalent?

That would probably be tricky to do. The arguments that use _normal should use the command name argument in order to determine completion. In the example I gave above that is accomplished by using the double colon form. It would also need to be aware of the terminator in order to know when to stop accepting arguments.