diff --git a/CRM/Case/XMLProcessor/Report.php b/CRM/Case/XMLProcessor/Report.php
index aa0b6c0b5215..bc7c47e85493 100644
--- a/CRM/Case/XMLProcessor/Report.php
+++ b/CRM/Case/XMLProcessor/Report.php
@@ -824,8 +824,8 @@ public static function printCaseReport() {
     $xmlProcessor = new CRM_Case_XMLProcessor_Process();
     $caseRoles = $xmlProcessor->get($caseType, 'CaseRoles');
     foreach ($caseRelationships as $key => & $value) {
-      if (!empty($caseRoles[$value['relation_type']])) {
-        unset($caseRoles[$value['relation_type']]);
+      if (!empty($caseRoles[$value['relation_type'] . '_' . $value['relationship_direction']])) {
+        unset($caseRoles[$value['relation_type'] . '_' . $value['relationship_direction']]);
       }
       if ($isRedact) {
         if (!array_key_exists($value['name'], $report->_redactionStringRules)) {