You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Automating a property with an LFO Controller works fine in real-time playback, but it seems to be only occasionally sampled on export (regardless of the file format AFAIK), and sounds "stepped" as a result
This is another issue with automatic signal-slot connections that should be direct instead. I fixed the ones in the core, LADSPA, and VST in #4692 and #4942, but didn't touch the built-in plugins.
Just took a leisurely stroll in the TripleOscillator's code to see if setting all the signals to be DirectConnections would fix this, and it did, and I'm definitely surprised that the fix is that small. But I'd venture to guess it would take a good chunk of time to add this fix to all of the plugins...
Firepal
changed the title
LFO Controller (occasionally?) exports poorly
LFO Controller/Automation exports poorly
Sep 21, 2020
I'm not currently working on this, so if you'd like to open a PR with your changes, that would be very welcome. Don't worry about fixing all the plugins at once - any fix is better than nothing.
Bug Summary
Automating a property with an LFO Controller works fine in real-time playback, but it seems to be only occasionally sampled on export (regardless of the file format AFAIK), and sounds "stepped" as a result
Steps to reproduce
LMMS project file
bugrep.zip
Listen to the project file first, and then export to WAV or some other format
Add an LFO Controller with any settings (Sine wave and tempo-synced to Eight Beats for example)
Connect it to a Coarse Detuning knob in the TripleOscillator
Add a pattern with a long note and play it in the Song Editor; the TripleOsc should sound fine as expected
Export it to some audio file format and listen to the exported file
Expected behavior
The exported audio file sounds like the real-time playback of LMMS with no issues
Actual behavior
The exported audio file has very noticeable "jumps" in the LFO Controller
Screenshot
A little comparison of an exported file from LMMS (top track) and recorded real-time output from LMMS (bottom track) in Audacity
![an Audacity screenshot of two tracks](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/29317321/91954367-fc305e80-ed01-11ea-8d89-24da76305a65.png)
bugrep-aup.zip
Affected LMMS versions
Branch: master. I've noticed this issue on stable 1.2.x as well.
This never occured in 1.1.3.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: